Transcript 0:00 Hello, welcome to the video. 0:01 My name is Mark, and for those of you who are familiar with this channel, um, in the recent-- in the past few weeks, Brandon, who founded the channel and is the, the normal contributor, he's invited me to join him with, um, s-sharing some ideas. 0:16 And predominantly what I'm gonna be looking at is how can I can contribute as a, as an older person to help or sort of add some depth to, to the, uh, the information and the education that we're able to share on this channel. 0:28 One of the things since I've started, uh, joining him is I've looked at a lot of the comments and a lot of the feedback that we've been receiving. 0:34 There's some common threads, and I'm gonna try and address a couple of those in one video today. The first thing that we hear a lot about is, you know, we're Canadians. 0:42 The majority of our audience is Canadians, and so we like to hear more about Canadian companies, um, and that's one of the main things I'm gonna talk about today. Another thing is this. 0:51 There's some major differences between, um, a senior or an older person, let's say even, you know, fifty plus, which is my demographic, and a millennial investor. 1:01 So when you're in your twenties or even in your thirties, your objectives, the way you manage money, and your mindset is quite different from someone who's older. 1:09 A common thing that we hear is the older people are too boring. You, you don't take on enough risk. 1:15 You're, uh, you know, there's opportunities that you leave on the table because, uh, if you invest in, say, smaller companies or you invest in more aggressive type companies, you can get rich quicker. 1:26 Um, we're gonna look at that today in the Canadian context, and specifically what we're gonna use as an example to demonstrate this concept is, uh, we're gonna use a couple, or actually three Canadian banks. 1:37 Now, as we probably all know, if you're a Canadian investor, you're going to be invested in the banking sector. 1:42 Now, whether you invest directly, if you own a mutual fund, I can assure you, uh, it will own Canadian banks. 1:49 Or heck, if you belong to a group RSP, a pension plan, um, most of those investments are going to hold Canadian banks. 1:56 Predominantly, what you're gonna see is the big Canadian banks, the big five banks, and those are Royal Bank, TD Bank, Bank of Montreal, CIBC, and Scotiabank. They get all the love. They get all the attention. 2:09 There's no problem at all finding research and opinions on, you know, when should you buy the banks, et cetera. 2:15 But there is another tier of banking in Canada too that doesn't get a lot of attention, and as an investor, not many people go to those that... You know, sort of that tier two level. 2:25 Some examples of companies in that range are companies like, uh, Laurentian Bank, uh, Canadian Western Bank, National Bank, um, Tangerine. 2:34 I mean, there, there are a whole bunch of them, but what we're gonna do for the video today is I'm gonna use three banks. So I'm gonna use Royal Bank as the proxy for large banks. 2:44 It is Canada's largest bank, so it kind of makes sense that we would use that. For the smallest bank, uh, I've chosen to highlight Canadian Western Bank. We'll talk a little bit about that in a moment. 2:54 That's gonna be the small. Then somewhere in the middle, uh, I'm gonna bring National Bank in, not necessarily to look at whether you should buy that bank or any of these banks for that moment. 3:02 This is not a video on what to buy today. It's a video on how they interact, how they're different, what are the similarities, what are the differences. This will help you make good longer term investing decisions. 3:13 Before we start, 'cause a lot of people probably haven't heard about Canadian Western Bank, I'm gonna give you a little bit of information about this bank as the smaller one. 3:21 So Canadian Western Bank, the ticker is CWB, and this is a-- as the name implies, it was founded in the west, um, of Canada, and it is headquartered in Edmonton. Now, 3:32 one of the things that Canadian Western Bank, it, it, it differentiates it from the big banks are that it, uh, highlights or focuses more on entrepreneurship. So it star-- it, it focuses more on small companies. 3:45 As you can see by this graph, although they are predominantly western based, they do have the bulk of their business loans in BC and Alberta, but they also have a very strong president-- uh, presence in Ontario. 3:57 And as you can see, they also have traction through the prairie provinces and out east as well. Their mission, as they've stated, is to solve for the unmet banking needs of Canadian entrepreneurs. 4:08 So by definition, they're going to have these relationships with entrepreneurs, much like the larger banks will be-- will have, but they're not gonna have that broad scope of offerings that the bigger banks have. 4:21 Are they safe? This is one of the things you always have to look at when you're looking at, um, comparing large companies to small companies. That's one of the big differentiating factors. So, um, are they safe? 4:31 Well, in a nutshell, I would say the answer to that is yes. As you can see by this next chart here, there is a measurement that we use in the, in the banking industry. 4:39 It's called common equity tier one capital, and this measures the liquidity or the safety that a bank would have, and it's designed to ensure that in the event of an economic stress, the bank is well capitalized. 4:51 As you can see here, the tier one capital, uh, ratios for Canadian Western Bank are very solid. 4:58 The right-hand column shows the regulatory minimum, and then you can see for Q1 2020 and Q1 2021, you're gonna see that, uh, in all cases, for each of the different measurements, the Canadian Western Bank is above the minimums and quite healthily. 5:12 Now, they're not as well capitalized as the Big Five, uh, but in general, anytime they're above that number, they're going to be secure. So is a smaller bank, um, you know, unsafe? Uh, I would say no. 5:26 I would say that there is safety there. So that's one thing out of the way. The next question we would ask is, you know, does size matter? How much bigger is-- are the big banks than the smaller banks? 5:36 So let's look at this, uh, comparison here. What you can see is that clearly the Royal Bank is the giant in Canada. 5:43 I mean, uh, TD Bank is close on its heels, but, but Royal Bank definitely has the largest marketal-- market capitalization today, and this comes in at, you know, around a hundred and sixty-three billion dollars. 5:54 In comparison, if we go to the smallest of the companies we're looking at today, the Canadian Western Bank has a market cap of three billion dollars. Now, it's almost a rounding error for a company like Royal Bank. 6:06 In the middle, we have the, uh, National Bank of Canada.So the National Bank has a market cap of around $29 billion as of today when I'm filming this video. So you can see how much larger Royal Bank is. 6:18 Then you go quite a ways down to the mid cap of the $29 billion and then right down to the smaller banks. Now, there are smaller banks than the Canadian Western Bank, to be sure. 6:26 But for a bank that we can get proper data on, some history on, this is a pretty good way of measuring that. Let's look at dividends, because when you're investing in general, we like dividend companies. 6:37 But specifically when you're looking at banks, banks tend to generate a lot of cash flow and they do tend to pay those dividends out to their shareholders. 6:45 So one of the things, if you're looking at the financial sector, they're always kind of known for having a strong dividend cash, dividend flow. So let's look and compare these. 6:54 One of the first things you're going to notice here is that all of the banks pay what I would call good, solid dividends. Royal Bank currently is paying the highest dividend of the three that we're comparing today. 7:06 But for all intents and purposes, I'm going to call them similar. If we look right down to Canadian Western Bank, I mean, they're paying 3.4% today compared to 3.8 for the Royal Bank. 7:15 Sure, I'd rather have a high dividend, but I still think that 3.4 in the market we're in today is very respectable. You will notice over, say, the last five-year time period, they're very consistent. 7:27 Generally speaking, you'll have seen the larger banks pay a higher dividend. But during the credit crisis, you'll notice that the dividend on Canadian Western Bank did spike up. 7:38 You look at the market opportunity that presented itself back in March of 2020. 7:42 So let's say a year ago now, there were some great opportunities to snap up shares of these companies or to increase the weighting that you already have and lock in some of those higher dividend yields, which were as high as 6% range and a little bit higher even. 7:54 Always something you need to look at when you're considering dividends is, are they safe? Are they going to continue to pay the dividend and hopefully raise them over time? 8:01 The dividend payout ratio, again, for each of these companies is very respectable. 8:05 In fact, the most secure, I guess you would say, would be the Canadian Western Bank, which has a 44% roughly dividend payout ratio right now, whereas the Royal Bank has about 55. 8:17 National Banks fits somewhere in the middle, just under 49%. In all cases and historically, there's been a lot of safety in those numbers. So from that perspective, I would say it's really a draw. 8:32 There's no difference between a big bank and a small bank when it comes to that cash flow and paying dividends. So ultimately, the question now comes down to, does size matter? 8:43 You're going to expect, you know, the old saying, risk versus reward. 8:46 So you're going to naturally expect that if you are owning a smaller company, you're going to expect more volatility, but you take it, you accept that volatility so that you can have a higher return at the end of the day. 8:58 Larger companies tend to be more stable. So we would almost expect that to be the case here. We're going to look at those numbers in just a second here. One of the measurements that we use, a statistical measurement to 9:09 measure how volatile an individual company is, is what's called the beta. Now, the beta essentially, it just compares an individual security, in this case, to a broader market. 9:21 So it will allow us to know how volatile this is in comparison to the market in general. As you can see here, the calculation of beta is very complex, and you don't have to learn this. What you have to remember is this. 9:35 When you compare a stock to an index, a beta of one means that that stock is more volatile than the index as a whole. A beta of under one means that the stock is less volatile. 9:47 A beta of one means that the stock will move exactly in comparison to the overall index. Now, this is very rare, but it could happen on a temporary basis. 9:57 But essentially, above one, more volatile, below one, less volatile. Not all of the stock quote pages that I've seen online offer you this beta right at the front, but one of the websites that does is Yahoo Finance. 10:11 And if you look at that, you're going to see right away what the beta of an individual stock is. 10:16 As you can see by this chart, there is a huge difference between the beta of a big bank like Royal Bank and a small bank like Canadian Western Bank in this case. 10:25 Now, as you might expect, you look at National Bank, it falls somewhere in the middle. This is kind of what we're taught. This is basic smaller equals more volatile. 10:32 If we look back over the last five years, the Royal Bank has been less volatile, significantly less volatile than the Canadian market in general. 10:41 You can see on this chart, the blue line represents the beta of Royal Bank and the thicker red line running down the middle is actually the index. 10:48 And in this case, I've used the Toronto Stock Exchange as a proxy for what we would compare these against. The most volatile has been Canadian Western Bank. 10:58 And you can see that for the entire five-year period that we're looking at here, it is traded at a beta above one. And right now it's currently trading at about 1.34. 11:06 So that's significantly more volatile than the market. National Bank has been for the most part more volatile, but there has been periods it's kind of gone back and forth a little bit during the five-year time period. 11:18 Of note, with the rare exception of late last year and earlier, or sorry, late 2019 and earlier 2020, the Royal Bank generally has traded at a lower beta, meaning less risky. So 11:33 we determined that the smaller bank is in fact more volatile than the big bank. So the trade-off, is it worth that risk? 11:43 Let's look at some of the historic returns from different timeframes to measure that and just see where that payoff might be. This chart will show us a 10-year number. 11:52 So in the Canadian banks, you're going to see here that the middle tier, so National Bank has come out the winner over the 10, and this is showing the price change during that time period. 12:02 The National Bank is up 132% during that timeframe. Royal Bank up 92, very respectable gains. You're going to notice Canadian Western Bank. 12:10 So in this case, the more volatile stock, the small bank came in at only 13% return. 12:17 So in this time measurement, I would argue that you have not been rewarded forHaving take for taking on more risk versus having a more secure, more stable portfolio. Let's move that out now to the twenty-year timeframe. 12:33 As we stretch that out, now this is very interesting. You'll see that over the longer term, the smaller bank has now taken the lead over the Royal Bank. 12:40 So in this case, you will see much like what you would expect in the smaller... The additional risk that you're accepting has actually benefited you. And it... 12:49 Although it's been much more volatile, and you look at the, you look at the ups and downs, the green line is the Canadian Western Bank, and it has been huge volatility swings compared to Royal Bank and National Bank. 12:59 You haven't quite, uh, made as much money as you would-- has with, uh, with National Bank. But certainly, uh, comparing small to big, hmm, maybe it did make sense that you would have taken on the, the extra risk. 13:10 Now, let's stretch that line right out to a forty-year number, and this is really where, you know, for a lot of investors my age, we have been investing probably for much of that time. 13:19 For younger investors, it's really hard, I know, to imagine if you're twenty years old today, if you're twenty-five years old today, it's hard to imagine that far out. 13:26 You know, you go out more than double your, your age from this point. But as we teach on this channel and as hopefully you, you know, investing is a long-term venture. 13:36 So the fact that you are having to visualize that, that extra forty years out, look at this as some evidence as to whether that would pay off or not. 13:44 This chart will show you that clearly over the long term, the, the large company has far exceeded the returns of the smaller companies. You'll see the Royal Bank coming in at three thousand percent. 13:55 Uh, this is just a price return. This is not even including dividends, which we've seen are very similar, but we've stripped those out for the purposes of demonstrating the price change here. 14:03 The dividends are all pretty much the same, so it shouldn't be a huge factor. Looking at this, you see, you see the Royal Bank at three thousand percent return over that forty-year time period. 14:11 Canadian Western Bank coming in second at about thirteen, just under fourteen hundred percent return, and just over a thousand percent is the National Bank of Canada. So in this case, you would... 14:21 You could argue that you... Well, you can argue very vehemently that you have not been rewarded. 14:26 So depending on the time period you're looking at, um, in this case, big, solid, steady banks have, uh, has, have produced the highest return. So we're gonna have a look now at special events. 14:38 So what happens when there's some unusual occurrence in the markets out there? 14:44 This is often where you're going to see the, the security of the larger companies, um, help you out, where the insecurity of the smaller companies might cause some additional stress. 14:54 We're going to compare a couple of, uh, scenarios that we've fairly recently gone through. 14:59 Uh, we're gonna look at the credit crisis back just over ten years ago now, or I guess getting closer to twelve years ago now, and we're also going to look at the more recent COVID timeframe, so going back a year, to see did it matter if you had a larger company or a smaller company? 15:13 When you look at this chart here, you're gonna see something very dramatically. 15:17 First of all, during the time period starting in two thousand eight running through to March of two thousand nine, the Toronto Stock Exchange was down, uh, just over forty-three percent during that time period. 15:29 You can see highlighted here how the various banks have behaved during a similar timeframe. 15:35 Clearly, the bigger banks in this crisis held on much better, with the Canadian Western Bank losing a, a huge seventy-two percent. 15:42 Um, the Royal Bank and the National Bank were certainly down in value, but nowhere close to what the smaller bank was, and in fact, both of the larger banks outperformed the broader Toronto Stock Exchange. 15:54 The takeaway from this chart, I would say, is that in times of trouble, yeah, bigger can be better. But let's now look at the recovery phase. So this is very interesting I find here. 16:05 We're gonna look at a chart that goes back from the March time period of two thousand nine up until the end of the year. So we've now been through the worst of the crisis. What happens then? 16:15 Well, in this, wow, Canada Western Bank made huge gains compared to the others, u-up about a hundred and seventy percent from the lows fro- of March through to the end of the year. 16:25 Um, the TSX gained, uh, about fifty percent during the same time period, and all of the banks outperformed during that recovery. So here is an example of where the smaller bank absolutely outperformed the bigger banks. 16:37 And you'll see if you had been able to take advantage of that, there certainly was an opportunity th-there. 16:44 Looking back through the entire cycle now, so from January two thousand eight up until the end of two thousand nine, both the National Bank and the Royal Bank fared okay. 16:53 The Canadian Western Bank, despite the huge gains coming out of the recovery, still ended up down twenty-six percent over the entire time period, and that was worse than the TSX overall. 17:04 You will note from this chart here that at no point did the Royal Bank or National Bank ever dip below where CWB or Canadian Western Bank is. 17:11 Another more recent event that we all went through about a year ago was the, the COVID, um, issue. So starting in, I guess, March, when the markets really reacted last year, we saw the huge dip in the market. 17:21 So let's have a look at that time period and compare again big banks and small banks. We see the exact same picture. 17:27 We see in that time period, so this goes back to, uh, well, it's goes from beginning of two thousand and twenty through till, uh, July two thousand and twenty. 17:36 You'll see the drop of all the banks starting right near the beginning of March, but it's the same picture. 17:41 You're gonna see Royal Bank, uh, you're gonna see the National Bank, I would say, dramatically outprove, uh, outperform the smaller Canadian Western Bank. So let me wrap this up and summarize here. 17:50 In general, we always advocate a larger, more secure company compared to a smaller, riskier company. In our opinion, generally speaking, over the longer term, the risk just isn't worth the reward. 18:03 And in fact, in this case, we've seen there isn't even a reward if you stretch the line out long enough. 18:07 As you can see from this chart, had you invested forty years ago in any of the large Canadian banks, you've done well. 18:13 I mean, clearly, TD Bank has been the, the, you know, the, the strong winner here, BMO coming in, in, in fifth place. But, um, next, no question about it, you've done well during that time. 18:24 Now-Is there an opportunity or are there opportunities along the way? The answer to that is yes. Um, it's unlikely you're gonna have a position and hold it entirely for a forty-year time period. 18:35 So if you, um, know what you're doing and if you are watching things carefully enough, certainly you may make some calls along the way. 18:43 And an example may be during the recent COVID crisis or during the credit crisis where you saw the smaller banks underperform so dramatically in a period of time. 18:53 If you check your metrics and you understand and you believe that there's still security, that may present an opportunity to shift, say, within the financial sector, maybe move some of the money you have from the larger banks, shift it into the lower, uh, lower tier banks with more opportunity. 19:08 But that has to be managed very carefully. If you had to just pick one and you, you weren't gonna manage it, um, in that manner, then pick the, the large banks. That would be, that would be our advice. 19:17 Uh, but if you do have the acumen, then, you know, you can take advantages of opportunities along the way. 19:22 It is our opinion that, um, in general, having w- uh, large, well-capitalized companies will serve you well through all types of market conditions, and in this case particular, it's best just to go with the larger banks unless you're really on top of things and want to take advantage of some opportunities along the way. 19:40 As always, if you've enjoyed the video, please give it a thumbs up. We really appreciate that support for the channel. Very interested in hearing your comments and your feedback, uh, below. 19:50 If you are a younger investor, can you even imagine forty years from now? 19:54 Does it make sense that you would buy something like the Royal Bank of Canada and essentially let that run for all those time periods, or is that nuts? 20:01 Would you say, "No, there's opportunities to go with some of the smaller companies like the Canadian Western Banks or the national banks and capitalize on those opportunities"? What are your thoughts on there? 20:10 If you're fifty or sixty, you may have owned these companies for decades. What has your experience been? Really looking forward to hearing your thoughts on that. 20:19 As always, um, if you do want to learn more about this type of, uh, of investment strategy, et cetera, we do have our investment academy, and there's a link just below this video here that you'll be able to click on and learn more about that. 20:29 Um, I'm gonna wrap up this video. I wanna thank you very much for watching. I really appreciate it, and I look forward to seeing you in the next video.