Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Hello, welcome to today's video. In case you haven't noticed, the markets are dropping. Um, as I'm filming this video today on, uh, Wednesday, the Dow is down around seven hundred points. 0:17 The Nasdaq continues to fall. It's down around seven percent, I think, from its recent highs. That doesn't concern me at all. 0:23 But I have been reading some comments online recently from, uh, presumably some newer investors, and it does concern me, and it's related to stop-loss orders. 0:31 And I've been reading things like, "I'm not worried about having these growth investments because I've got stop-loss orders on my portfolio." 0:38 And there's, um, I would say, quite a misinterpretation of what stop-loss orders can do. You think it might be buying you protection or a guarantee, but that's not necessarily the case. 0:49 So I'm gonna be talking today about that. Now, a quick note, I'm only gonna be talking about stop-loss on long positions. So this means you already own the stock. 0:58 You can buy stop buys against companies that you have sold short. It's not used very often, especially by our office, uh, by, by our viewers. 1:07 So I'm going to just skip over that and focus on what affects most of us here, which are you own a long position, you wanna buy a stop-loss pr-- to protect against downside there. 1:17 I'm also gonna take a deeper dive into what, uh, you know, not only what, uh, stop-loss orders are and how to do them, but more importantly, how can they help you? 1:26 I'm gonna look at some studies that show, you know, some academic studies that show, really, is there a good, uh, use for them? Are they overblown? 1:35 You know, when you read the comments online, you're gonna see all kinds of, you know, "I never use them," or, "I always use them," or, "You should never buy a stock without having a stop on it," or, you know, "Stocks are gonna ruin your perf- your performance overall." 1:47 Let's look at all of those scenarios. And lastly, I'm just gonna talk about how to use them. How can you implement in a strategy? So first of all, let's star- start with what are stop losses. 1:57 So i- in general, they are a type of order that is designed to limit losses on a portfolio. So they are a risk reduction strategy. Now, how do they work? 2:09 They help trading risk by specifying a price at which your position that you already own will be sold. Essentially, you enter an order at a specified price, and it's executed automatically if that price is reached. 2:25 In other words, if a price falls below your stop price, your stock is automatically sold at the next available market price. 2:33 There are different types of stop-loss orders, so we're gonna look at the, the major ones right now. The first, I'm just gonna talk about a traditional stop loss. So how does this work? 2:42 You own a stock, and you set a price that will trigger the order. So this price is set manually, and it's adjusted only if you decide. 2:51 It's at your discretion whether you're gonna move that price up or down on the stop, uh, target. 2:57 As an example, your stock is trading at fifty dollars a share, and you feel that you can afford to, you know, let it move a little bit. You're willing to take, in this case, I'm gonna say a five dollar loss. 3:07 S-so you set your stop price at forty-five dollars. When your stock does move below forty-five dollars, your order will be entered. But importantly, that forty-five dollar price isn't guaranteed. 3:20 If the stock gaps down to below forty-five dollars, in a traditional stop loss, you will sell at whatever price or very close to whatever price it opens at. So how does that work? 3:32 A stock gaps when it opens from one trading session or opens-- closes at one, in one trading session and opens in the next trading session at a significantly lower amo- a-amount. 3:42 So it's not unheard of where you have a tr-- a stock trading at, say, fifty dollars a share. Overnight, some news comes in. 3:48 Maybe an analyst, uh, downgrades the stock or maybe there's an after-hours release and the earnings aren't where people want them to be. There can be a number of different reasons. 3:56 A lawsuit is launched, that type of thing. Well, that stock may open at forty dollars the next day. 4:03 So if you have a traditional stop-loss order, your trade will be entered at a market order, as a market order, at that forty dollar price because it changes from a limit order to a market order. 4:16 It's a little bit confusing, but the point is you're not guaranteed the forty-five dollars and a lot of people think that when they have a, a stock and they put that stop price, they're guaranteed that number. 4:26 That's simply not true. There is another type of stock, uh, a stop loss that I'm going to talk about called a trailing stop loss. 4:33 The difference here is that instead of setting a price, in the previous example I used forty-five dollars, you set a percentage or a dollar amount which is below the current price. 4:45 That amount, that price is automatically adjusted to the most recent high that that stock has traded at. So let's look at an example of this. Again, you have a stock that's trading at fifty dollars right now. 4:57 You set a target price as a percentage or a dollar amount below. Let's use ten percent as the percentage amount and let's use five dollars as the dollar amount. 5:06 So in this case, the trailing stop will be set to forty-five dollars in both cases because ten percent less than fifty is forty-five and five dollars less than fifty is forty-five. 5:18 Scenario one now, that stock moves to sixty dollars. 5:22 That price, your stop price will now be adjusted and your ten percent will now be adjusted to fifty-four dollars because the new sixty dollar price minus ten percent is sixty-four doll- fifty-four dollars and the dollar amount will now be placed at fifty-five dollars because sixty dollars minus your trailing of five dollars is fifty-five. 5:44 Next scenario, that stock now takes a big run and it moves up to a hundred dollars a share. Your ten percent trailing stop is automatically adjusted. 5:52 Ten percent off of a hundred is now ninety so your new stop price becomes ninety and your five dollarStop price becomes ninety-five, five dollars off of a hundred. 6:04 I would say this is a better way of managing stop loss orders than simply the traditional order. Imagine if your stock rises to a hundred dollars like we just talked about. 6:13 The original traditional stop loss order, you have set a price of forty-five dollars. Now you have a huge gap. 6:20 So instead of protecting that ten percent that you originally had put in place, your hundred dollar trading price, you're now only protecting it down as far as forty-five. 6:28 So there is a lot of room to move in the meantime, whereas a trailing will fill that gap in, and it happens automatically. The last type of order I'm going to talk about now is what's called a stop limit order. 6:39 With this order, you actually have two prices. You have your stop price, and you have a limit price. The stop price is what triggers the order. 6:47 That's the same as before, but the limit price determines whether the sale is made or not. Let me give you an example of this. 6:55 Your XYZ stock is trading at fifty dollars a share, and you want to sell ten percent lower at forty-five dollars with a stop limit order. 7:04 Now, if the stock gaps below forty-five dollars, as we talked about earlier, your stock will not be sold unless it goes back up to forty-five dollars or higher. 7:15 But as soon as it reaches forty-five dollars or higher, it will be sold. So those are sort of the mechanics of how stop loss orders work. 7:22 Let's look now at some of the benefits and why you might consider putting these, say, this arrow into your quiver and using some of these. 7:30 The first and most obvious is if you use these properly, it can help manage losses. 7:34 I mean, clearly, it's an automatic system of making sure that even if you're not paying attention, the stock drops, you will, uh, you will be able to trigger a, a protective trade on the downside. 7:46 It's also used for locking in profits. So imagine you have a, uh, a stock that has gone up quite a bit. So this is where trailing stops would come in. 7:56 Stock's going up, you're letting it run, and as the price is going up, your limit or your downside, your stop price continues to go up with it. If that trend is developing, you can ride the wave up. 8:07 But as long as you have that, the share price or, or the stop price adjusted in there, in the event of a market turn, you will be provided some protection on the downside. 8:17 This type of a trade is also very valuable if you can't monitor the markets, and this could be for a number of reasons. 8:23 Some people just don't spend their whole day sitting in front of a computer, um, or, you know, even every week or every month monitoring their portfolios. 8:31 So if a company that you own starts to turn south, um, well, it'll still be protected even if you're not watching it. 8:39 Another very common, even for active traders, a common way that you would use or a reason you would use these is, you know, back in the days when you could go on vacation and you may be out of an area where you don't even have access to your portfolio, you may put some stops on specifically during that timeframe to protect you to some degree while you're gone. 8:56 Another really good advantage in the stop, uh, stop loss trading is that there are no costs. There's, you know, there's, they're free to put onto a trade. It's like free insurance almost on the downside. 9:07 There is another way you can protect, which is by, uh, buying protective puts on the downside, put options, but, uh, they're a little bit more complicated and also there is a cost involved in those. 9:19 So they are different. They're similar in that they provide downside protection, but don't confuse one with the other. But an advantage of the stop loss or- order is that there is, um, no cost to do that. 9:32 Another very valuable use of stop loss orders, especially for newer, well, I would say for anybody, but especially for newer investors, is it helps you with your emotions and it prevents or it can prevent what's called loss aversion. 9:49 It, it's very hard when you buy a stock and it drops in value to, you know, pull the trigger and sell it. 9:55 We have a built-in, uh, bias in our bodies to, you know, the, the, the emotions are, make it harder to sell that stock. 10:02 And so by having a stock, uh, a stop loss in place, it can help you mitigate the damages of those negative emotions, and it can force a discipline upon you that you might not, uh, get otherwise. 10:14 Let's look at some of the risks, and these are really important to understand. 10:19 The most important risk or the biggest risk, I would think, and I've seen this on the online comments, is it gives the investor a false sense of security. 10:29 Stop loss orders don't guarantee a specific price, even though you might feel like they do. 10:35 And, you know, I, I mentioned people will feel like, well, I, you know, I bought it at fifty, it's at a hundred, I've, I got a stop in at ninety, and I'm guaranteed that price. 10:44 Going back a few minutes ago when I talked about gaps, uh, for whatever reason that gap occurs, you can end up selling your stock at a much lower price than you anticipated. 10:55 Or if you had a stock limit and it drops, it blows through that limit price, you might not be able to sell the stock at all. 11:02 It'll just turn into a market order, but you're still owning it, and if it continues to go down, you're gonna be along for that, uh, for that ride. 11:09 Another unintended consequence that can happen when you're, when you're placing stop lo- loss limits is that you could get stopped out of a position. You have a stock that trades in a r-- you know, a range. 11:20 Well, if it takes a dip, a- and if that dip is short term in, in nature, well, that fluctuation could cause you to be sold out of a position. 11:29 So it goes from fifty to forty-five, it's triggered, you're sold out, and if that stock now goes up again, you're no longer owning that. 11:38 And if you're paying attention, if you're monitoring properly, well, then you would notice that, and you could make a decision whether you wanted to get back in or not. 11:46 But if you're not monitoring it, and that's very common, well, you know, it could be some time later before you even realize that you don't own the stock anymore. 11:53 You see some good news on the company, you, you know, check in to see how much money you've made on it, and the answer is nothing beyond what- whatever you may have originally made because you no longer are an owner. 12:03 You got stopped out of that position unknowingly. Another thing to be aware ofAs a newer user of stop loss orders is the fact that, that these are transparent market orders. 12:14 They're, they're on the system with a, with a price, a target price. 12:17 Sophisticated traders, the computer algorithms, the market makers out there will actually be able to, I, I would say, take advantage of that, and they can anticipate and, and they perform what they call they, they run the stops. 12:30 In other words, they know that at a certain level, now whether it's a resistance level, maybe a technical trading level, or quite often like sort of a nice round number, it's, you know, if, if your stock's trading at fifty, you'll place your stop loss at forty-five, not necessarily forty-five twelve. 12:46 Now, the sophisticated traders will know where these are. When the stock drops to that level, you're typically gonna see a, a, a spike in volume as all of these trades get closed. 12:57 If you know what you're doing, you can take advantage of that sort of naivety and, uh, capitalize, buy those up if you feel that the stock is gonna be turning back into a positive direction. 13:08 So what do the scholars say about stop loss strategies? Should we use them? Shouldn't we use them? 13:13 As is often the case, there's a bit of a divergence of opinion there, but let's look at three studies today to help us understand and formulate our decisions. 13:21 The first study that we're gonna look at today is a two thousand and seven study by Katherine Komisky and Andrew Lo, and it's entitled, "When Do Stop Loss Rules Stop Losses?" That's a logical question to ask. 13:33 The report they use in this data is from nineteen fifty, uh, to two thousand and four, so it's a fifty-year time period. 13:40 In the report, they say that the purpose is t- is to illustrate the practical relevance of our framework, and they use empirical analysis of a stop loss policy applied to a buy and hold strategy in US equities. 13:53 Now this is something whether it's US or Canadian or European, this is a strategy that a lot of investors use, and so I think it's very relevant. 14:01 Does a stop loss strategy help in a strategy l- in, in a, uh, a long-term buy and hold strategy like that? 14:07 They go on to say in their report, "This passive approach to investing is often contradicted by human behavior, especially during periods of market turmoil. 14:16 These behavioral biases sometimes lead investors astray," I would say often, "causing them to shift their portfolio weights in response to significant swings in market indexes, often selling at a low and buying at a high." 14:32 In this study, they conclude by saying, "If stopping losses is interpreted as having a higher expected return with the stop loss policy than without it, then for a specific binary stop loss policy, we derive various conditions under which the expected return difference, which we call the stopping premium, is positive." 14:51 In other words, they are saying that in their study, there was a benefit, uh, some of it emotionally related, to having a consistent stop loss policy in place than not. 15:03 They o-- they go on to say, "As difficult as it may be to accept, for the millions of investors who lamented after the bursting of the technology bubble in two thousand that 'If only I got out earlier, I wouldn't have lost so much,' they may have been correct." 15:17 They are in support or their study says or suggests that there is a benefit to having a stop loss policy in place on a long buy and hold. The second study we're gonna look at today is from Stockholm. 15:28 It's from the Stockholm School of Economics, uh, two thousand and eight, called "The Efficiency of Stop Loss Rules." 15:35 They studied all stocks in the Stockholm thirty index from January two thousand and six to two thousand and eight, a much shorter time period. 15:43 And in the study, they say, "We examine the efficiency of such stop loss rules by measuring their marginal impact on expected return and risk, proxied by volatility in comparison with the classic buy and hold strategy." 15:56 In their study, they conclude, "We find strong evidence that stop loss rules have a negative marginal impact on the expected return of a buy and hold portfolio strategy." 16:08 They go on to say, "We find that the marginal impact in expected returns for stop loss rules is significantly negative on a buy and hold strat- portfolio strategy, and even if stop loss rules reduce the volatility on a buy and hold portfolio strategy, it does not compensate for the reduction in expected returns." 16:28 They conclude, "Despite the strength of our evidence, it is inconsistent with the empirical findings presented by Komisky and Lo in two thousand and seven since they found a positive marginal impact." 16:40 So here you have two studies which essentially are giving you total opposite, y- you know, opinions or total o-opposite conclusions on whether a stop loss strategy is effective or not. 16:53 The last study we're gonna look at today is from twenty fifteen. Um, the Faculty of Business and Law from the Open University in Milton Keynes in the UK. They study what's called the disposition effect. 17:05 Now, a disposition effect is a, a, a behavioral bias where people have a disposition, an inclination, to hold onto losing stocks longer than they hold onto winning stocks. And it's just, this is part of human nature. 17:20 When stocks go down, we want to continue to hold them. So the study is looking at how do stop loss rules or, or stop loss strategies help counter that. 17:30 To summarize their study, they're saying that, "In this study, we argue that a relatively easy way to reduce the disposition effect is through the use of stop losses, since stop losses can automate an exit strategy, reducing reliance on investors' impulse control." 17:46 This next part is really important for most of you listening today. 17:50 "We found that stop loss users tend to be younger than investors who do not use stop losses, implying that they are a trading strategy more often used by investors with less experience." 18:03 And their quote says, "Thus, less sophisticated and less experienced investors could use stop losses while learning to invest, thereby safeguarding their portfolio whilst gaining knowledge."This is really relevant to the times that we're living in right now, where essentially a-all of the reports acknowledge that the stop loss strateg-- uh, strategies are used less by the professional managers than they are by individuals. 18:31 And that's probably just a function of if your whole job is to spend all day watching this with your team of analysts, it's less likely you're going to miss something and more likely that you're going to have the opportunity to react, uh, to, uh, a move in one of your stock prices without having that automatic, uh, trade trigger. 18:51 So how do we use these in our strategies? First and most importantly, I would say is you need to understand what you're doing. Stop loss or-orders seem simple enough, but they're not a silver bullet. 19:04 They're not a panacea for eliminating downside risk on your portfolio, and they do have a-- There's a tendency to believe that that's the case. 19:13 If you're a longer term trader, you may consider having a larger gap, let's say, you know, fifteen percent or twenty percent, where you're going to allow for the market to move up and down without triggering those sales. 19:24 If you're a short-term trader, if you're a day trader, well, clearly, you're not going to want a fifteen or twenty percent, uh, movement. There'll be a much tighter stop price set on there. 19:33 Pick a stop price that allows for day-to-day fluctuations. This is something that is often ignored, and if you're not monitoring things, you get stocks that, you know, some stocks move quite dramatically. 19:45 If a stock moves, say, you know, ten percent a week or a month on average, well, setting a, a stop limit at five percent isn't gonna make much sense. 19:52 That strategy won't work because you're just gonna be continually stopped at a position. So understand the investment, understand the, the volatility. 19:58 Maybe you look at the beta numbers on it and see what you can expect and set your stop prices, um, a-accordingly. 20:06 An alternative strategy to using stop losses in the first place, and this is what I do primarily, is to use alerts. 20:13 Most platforms today will al-allow you to set price alerts, and instead of using stop losses, you can set the alerts and just say, you know, at this particular company, I... 20:21 If it drops five percent or fifteen percent or whatever number it makes sense to you right now, you will be notified basically instantaneous. 20:30 I mean, today with, with cell phones and there's very, there's very, uh, few times that you're out of touch, and if you set an alert, it's exactly that. 20:38 It doesn't mean you have to be monitoring it constantly, but you will-- it will be brought to your attention. And assuming you have the wherewithal to make a proper decision, you may analyze that. 20:48 You might say, "Oh, this looks like a temporary dip. Continue to hold the position." What you want to avoid is, you know, what we talked about earlier, where you have that loss aversion bias kick in. 20:58 So it's not for everyone, but it does allow more, uh, flexibility, more leeway if you are aware that the stock has dropped. 21:06 But instead of automatically getting stopped out, you can make that decision on your, on your, uh, by yourself. Big, a big important factor, are you a trader or are you an, an investor? 21:15 I know I kind of talked about this already, but if you're a hardcore buy and h- buy and hold investor, the need for stop losses is probably much less. 21:26 Mind you, if you're an active trader, then, uh, you know, there may-- they may play more of a role in what you're doing. I will wrap up this video and just say thank you very much for watching the video. 21:35 I hope that it's added to, to your toolkit, and that's what we're always trying to do is, is, you know, what, uh, what skills, what arrows can you put in that quiver that can help you? 21:45 Whether you use them immediately or at some point down the road, uh, it's good to be aware of them. 21:49 As always, the first link below is for our investing academy, and we do have trading for all levels of investors and, and so if that's something you're interested in, click the, the link down below. 21:59 Uh, if you'd like, uh, appreciate if you subscribe to the channel, give us a thumbs up, a like. 22:03 That really helps the algorithm, helps us, you know, continue to bring, you know, our information, our knowledge to more and more, um, viewers. Really appreciate that. I will wrap up. 22:14 I will say thank you so much for watching, and I look forward to seeing you in the next video.