Transcript 0:00 On a recent video that I posted on the topic of covered call ETFs, I got some really good questions covering, in general, a couple of key areas that seemed to need clarification. 0:08 For example, Dean Bryson says, "Once the shares are sold, the fund must then rebuy some more shares." And he says, "No one talks about the reinvesting mechanics." D Anderson added to the thread. 0:19 He said, "This is something I have asked before, but I'm yet to get a reasonable answer." And in this video today, I'm gonna make every effort to answer those questions. 0:27 On the same topic, Dividend Duck says, "While his explanation was fairly detailed, I think he could have touched on what would happen to HMAX in the event that the fund needs to buy back shares at a higher price after the calls are exercised by the other party." 0:41 And Michael added, "In a rising market, don't they have to buy back their optioned positions the next month at a loss? That is, at a higher price than what they just sold them for in the option." 0:52 Really understandable questions tr- trying to clarify the math behind these, uh, covered call ETFs. The second major area that was covered was this concept of losing your dividend. 1:02 Uh, TD says, "The B&S dividend in your math will probably be half that because the odds are the calls will get exercised before the ex-dividend date, and you won't get the dividends on half of the shares." 1:14 Gustavo says, and I'm assuming he's saying this somewhat sarcastically, "Shh. Don't tell anyone that part." Well, in this video today, I am going to tell you that part. I'm gonna talk about that. 1:23 PM says, "The other concern is if the shares are called away before the ex-dividend date, then they lose the dividend." 1:30 And D Anderson adds again, "That results in the sale of your holding, which would also include loss of the dividends that it was generating." 1:37 So is it true that with the covered call ETFs, A, if the shares are called away, you lose the dividend? The answer is no. I'll explain that here. 1:44 Secondly, the concept of will you lose money if the shares are exercised at a higher price and you have to buy them back? I'm going to cover all of those questions, or both of those questions, in the video today. 1:56 Something that's really important to note here, when we're talking about these covered call ETFs, we are talking about funds with tens or even hundreds of millions of dollars in them. 2:04 We're talking about funds that have, in some cases, millions of shares of the-- of the underlying companies that they own in the portfolio. 2:11 The strategies that we're talking about here probably won't work for the aver- well, they won't work for the average person. They probably won't work for you. 2:19 You need to have extremely large volumes, big chunks of money, in order to make these, um, strategies work. You need to have cash flow. You need to have size. 2:27 I just thought I'd point that out because if you're thinking these strategies apply to the average person on the street, um, the answer is, uh, they don't. They apply only to these large, large funds. 2:36 In this video, I'm going to use two examples. Now, one of these examples is extremely, extremely simple. 2:42 The first one is gonna be so simple, um, in concept that it's not a realistic example, but I'm putting it in to show the math to answer one of these questions. 2:50 The second strategy, the second example, will be a little bit more realistic with a larger volume, uh, but even that will pale in comparison to what you actually see on the street. 2:59 So let's start with example number one, and I'm gonna call this portfolio Ike. So in this scenario, Ike owns two shares of XYZ stock at fifty dollars each, so the total portfolio value is one hundred dollars. 3:12 Ike sells options, in this case, on both of his shares. So he sells at-the-money options with a fifty-dollar strike price and a thirty-day expiration. For this, he receives two dollars in premiums. 3:24 When we add this up, you've got a hundred dollars in shares, you've got two dollars in premiums, for a total portfolio value now of a hundred and two dollars. 3:34 During the thirty-day holding period, XYZ rallies from fifty dollars to a hundred. And as I said, this is probably not a realistic example, but I wanna show the math. So we're going... 3:43 You're, you're doubling the share price here. Obviously, in this case, both shares are gonna get called away. Ike now owns zero shares because everything was called away. 3:53 But of course, he gets a hundred dollars from the options holder, so he now has a hundred dollars in cash plus the two dollars in premiums that he collected. His portfolio value is now a hundred and two dollars. 4:06 Now, this is a critical part of the strategy here. Ike now goes out, and he immediately buys one new share of the company, which, of course, now is trading at a hundred dollars a share. 4:16 So he owns one share at a hundred dollars. He owns two dollars in premiums still in the portfolio. The portfolio value, again, is a hundred and two dollars. 4:25 So in this extreme example, this sort of illustrates how even though the share price has doubled, the value of the portfolio is maintained. You're just gonna end up, uh, owning sh- fewer shares at the end of the day. 4:36 And if we're looking at this extreme example of only owning two, obviously that couldn't be perpetuated. 4:41 But in a few moments here, we're gonna look at a more realistic example, um, in the real world of how this strategy would work. Okay, so let's address the dividend side of this equation here now. 4:50 Let's assume that stock XYZ has a dividend yield of five percent. 4:54 In the first scenario, where Ike owned two shares that were worth a hundred dollars, five percent of a hundred is obviously five dollars a year that he would receive in dividends. 5:03 Once he has gone through this transaction of repurchasing the shares, he now owns one share at a hundred dollars in value. Still, five percent of a hundred dollars is five dollars a year. 5:13 So in this scenario, despite owning fewer shares, in this case one versus two, he's still gonna be collecting the same five dollars a year in dividends. 5:21 Again, this only works if he goes out and repurchases those shares at-- you know, immediately. A- and that's basically the way these things work. 5:30 The fund managers, when their shares are called away, they will go out and immediately replace those. 5:36 Another question that comes up with dividends, and I didn't read this in comments last time, but I can anticipate, yes, but if the share price goes upYour dividend yield is going to go down. 5:47 If we look at a historic example here, I'm just going to use TD Bank as the example here. If we look at the orange line, that's the 20-year share price of TD. 5:56 If we look at the dividends per share, which is the blue dotted line, that is the dividends per share. 6:00 And you can see that a major goal of the Canadian banks or of many companies is to keep the dividend in proportion overall to the share price. 6:09 So it's realistic to expect that, yes, as the share price rises, the dividend would rise along with that. So let's sort of use that as a benchmark when we're looking at these scenarios here. 6:20 Hey, folks, as many of you know, in addition to this YouTube channel, we also have the Investing Academy. 6:25 This is our online platform, and we work with Canadians of all ages from across the country to help educate about investing and financial issues in general. 6:33 The course material is designed to take you from a raw beginner to a fully confident investor. 6:39 Now it's time to dedicate an entire module to the topic of dividends, because as I told you guys, they are that darn important. I will put a link in the description of this video and maybe check us out. 6:51 Now back to the video. I want to look now at example number two, which is sort of a bit of a more realistic example with some bigger numbers. And I'm going to call this example ETF Co. And in this case, ETF Co. 7:02 owns 2,000 shares of stock ABC trading at $50 a share. So the total portfolio value is $100,000. In this case, the ETF sells options on 1,000 of those shares at $1 per option. 7:17 So instead of 100% of the portfolio, like example one, we're now only writing shares on 50% of the portfolio. Again, they're selling at the money options with a $50 strike price with a 30-day expiration date. 7:29 So in this scenario, the fund receives $1,000 in premiums. So we do the math on this. We've got $100,000 worth of shares. We've got $1,000 of premiums. So the total portfolio value is $101,000. 7:43 Over the next 30 days, in this case, ABC goes up from $50 a share to $53 a share, much more realistic scenario. In this case, of course, 1,000 of ETF Co.'s 2,000 shares are going to be called away. 7:58 So if we look at this now, ETF Co. 8:00 owns $53,000 worth of shares, which is the 1,000 remaining, which are now worth $53 a share, $50,000 in cash from the options that were exercised, and $1,000 in cash from the options premiums. 8:15 So $53,000 in shares, $50,000 in cash, $1,000 from the premiums. Total portfolio value in this case is $104,000. Okay, so this is really critical now to the strategy as we just talked about. ETF immediately goes out. 8:31 I mean, talking that same day, they go out and they buy 943 shares of company ABC at $53 a share because that's the new share price. The 943 shares times $53, the new price, costs them $49,979. 8:47 This leaves them with $21 in cash. Plus, of course, they have cash in the portfolio from the options premiums that they wrote at $1,000. So if we sort of summarize everything, $102,979 worth of shares. 9:01 They've got 1,943 shares at $53 each. They've got $1,021 cash on hand. Total portfolio value is $104,000. 9:13 If we look at what I would call the key takeaways from this strategy here, the total portfolio during this 30-day time period went from $100,000 to $104,000. ETF Co. raised $1,021 that they can use for distributions. 9:27 And keep in mind that the various ETF companies distribute different. They have different formulas. 9:31 Some of them have target ratios that they will distribute each time regardless of whether the portfolio brings that money in during that time period. Others only will distribute and flow through whatever they earn. 9:44 So if the portfolio brings in $1,021 during that time period, that's what they would distribute. In the scenario we just looked at here, the stock price is up 6% during the course of the month. 9:55 The total return on the fund, though, is 4%. Remember here, 50% of the upside of the portfolio is capped because of the covered call strategy. But when you do the math on this, the stock itself was up 6%. 10:07 It went from $50 to $53 during the course of the month. That's a 6% increase. The fund in this case was up 4%. Now, that is more than 50% upside. 10:17 I mean, you might expect that because it's capped at 50%, if the stock goes up 6%, the fund itself will go up only 3%. But because of the covered call overlay, the upside is actually 4% in this case. 10:28 So that's more than that 50%. So that's an interesting twist sort of on how the math works on this. The dividend scenario in this case, stock ABC has a dividend yield we talked about earlier of 5%. 10:39 So with a $100,000 portfolio times 5%, the fund would expect to receive $5,000 in dividend distributions each year. In new scenario, their shares are now worth $102,979. 10:51 If you take 5% dividend distribution on that, you're looking at $5,148.95 a year despite owning fewer shares. The math behind these covered call option strategies can be really, really confusing. 11:04 And unfortunately, that leads to a lot of mistrust of the sector in general. There are lots and lots of misunderstandings, lots of myths out there. 11:12 For full context, watch this video right here, which will cover those in more detail. As always, the link for our Investing Academy is in the description below. 11:19 Thank you for watching this video, and I look forward to seeing you in the next video.