Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Ain't a cloud in the sky, ain't a worry on my mind. Looks like we're in the clear, clear, clear. Just a living the life, cool breeze in my hair Practically every Canadian investor owns the Canadian banks. 0:12 And of course, you know, why not? Their banks are considered here one of the most, uh, solid banking systems in the entire world. They pay good dividend yields, they're reliable. It makes sense. 0:21 A question we get a lot is, "Should I own these banks individually? Should I own s- direct shares of the companies, or should I use an ETF?" And, you know, what, what are the, uh, pros and cons of that? 0:38 Uh, in the video today, we're gonna look at what things you need to consider to make this choice, uh, which one is best for you. At the end of the day, it's your money. 0:45 Uh, we have to look at the pros, the cons, your circumstances, and, uh, we're gonna try and help you make that decision today. And this is one of those situations where there truly is no right or wrong answer. 0:54 It really comes down to your personal choices, to your discretion, and it is based... To be done properly, it's based on a number of different factors. 1:03 And in the video, I'm just looking forward to going through those various scenarios to help you, uh, steer yourself in the right direction. This video today, uh, I'm having a very, very focused objective. 1:15 I'm not gonna talk about, I'm not gonna say what, in my opinion, what the best bank ETF is. In Canada, there are so many different choices if you wanna go out and, uh, buy a representation of banks in an ETF. 1:27 There are so many choices, there's so many varieties of them out there. There's ETFs that, uh, cover, they own the banks, and they have maybe covered call strategies that they lay over, uh, owning the companies. 1:37 They have... There's some that have leverage. There's, uh, financial ETFs, which are heavily weighted in the banks, but they also might have other financials like, um, the insurance companies, et cetera. 1:47 The, the purpose of today's video isn't to, uh, narrow th- that field down. 1:51 The purpose really is to compare apples to apples and to take the owning the stocks directly and get the best representation of an ETF that I can. 1:58 And I'm gonna use two ETFs, uh, two Canadian ETFs in my example here today to try and, and give the best representation as possible. The first ETF we're gonna use is ZEB, which is the BMO Equal Weight Banks Index ETF. 2:12 The strategy of this ETF is to replicate as much as possible the Solactive Equal Weight Canada Banks Index. As the name implies, it's an equal representation of the, the six big banks in Canada. 2:23 If we look at the top holdings in this fund, well, there are only six, and as you can see, for the most part, they are equally balanced. 2:29 There will be some variation because the markets move every day, uh, but when they are rebalanced, they go back into that equal weight, uh, distributed amongst the six banks. 2:37 If we look at the actual Solactive Index as of January 19th, 2022, uh, you will see a very similar weighting, the lowest being roughly 15%, the National Bank of Canada, TD Bank, uh, the highest weighting at 18.13%. 2:50 The second fund we're gonna look at is the RBC Canadian Bank Yield Index ETF, which is RBNK. That's the ticker. The differentiating factor between this and ZEB is that this tracks the Solactive Canada Bank Yield Index. 3:05 This index is comprised of Canada's six largest bank, determined by market capitalization, and then weighted based on their indicative annual dividend yields. 3:13 So this results in actually a very significant change, a variation. 3:18 If we look at the specific holdings of these funds, we're gonna see the National Bank representing today only 7.43% of the overall portfolio, where we see Bank of Nova Scotia at the top of 25.44, and that is a function of just the, the yield and how this particular fund is, is nuanced. 3:36 I want to use these two particular funds to represent the broader sector, uh, for the purposes of the analysis today. 3:41 If you, uh, want to learn more about investing in banks, I've prepared a video before, and I've posted it, which compares investing big banks, the largest Canadian banks, to smaller banks, and, um, I, I'll post a link here to the, to the video if that's something that interests you too, and it, it's a deeper dive into the analysis of that comparison. 4:00 But for the purposes of this video, let's look at what types of things we might wanna consider when we're making this decision, ETFs versus individual securities, and there are a lot of things to consider. 4:10 Uh, it's not quite simple cut and dry. Uh, first thing that comes to mind is things like, well, what are your objectives? As an investor, um, what are you trying to accomplish with the portfolio? 4:19 We'll get into some more details in just a moment here, but assess things like, uh, what is your experience? Importantly, what is your confidence? A lot of people... 4:28 You know, it's probably easier to buy an ETF, more challenging to go out and build a portfolio of individual securities, but that will really come down to your comfort level in, in managing, uh, those aspects. 4:40 Another big thing you need to consider is what is your t- what are your time, uh, allowances? 4:45 And if you're a busy person swamped with getting the kids around to different activities, uh, working long hours, or just, you know, you have other interests that don't allow you to spend that much time monitoring your portfolio, that will also 4:57 play a role in whether you're going to go with the ETF basket type route or buying individual securities. 5:03 If we look specifically at ETFs and look at some of the pros there, the first one that just jumps out, uh, very, uh, easily is it's, it's easy. It's easier than buying individual securities. 5:14 It's really like a sort of almost like a, a hands-off experience. You make that initial decision. You don't have to give it any thought after that. The, the rebalancing is done automatically by the fund itself. 5:25 In the case, uh, like the fund, the RBank that we looked at, where, uh, depending on what the, the yields are, those things are all taken care of behind the scenes. 5:33 It kind of is a set-and-forget-it strategy if that is something that appeals to you, if that's, you know, if that's, uh, one of your objectives, as I said about earlier, if that's something you want to accomplish. 5:43 Another really key reason that you might wanna consider using ETFs versus individual securities, uh, going back to your experience, your comfort level, you can really use an ETF in the banking industry or in any industry for that sector, or for that matter, as a, uh, a stepping stone where you can gain some experience in the market. 6:01 B- if you're just a new investor, you can, uh, experience actually-You know, having your money invested, learning how the markets work, uh, and taking this sort of broader, more diversified step where you're not doing the actual day-to-day managing, but you are, uh, you know, part of that- part of the ride, uh, can be very benefit there as sort of a first step into the markets. 6:21 Another reason that you see people buying ETFs versus individual securities is depending on the amount of your account. 6:26 If it's a smaller account, then, uh, you can definitely benefit from the, the diversification of an ETF where you get, um, you know, more diversification built in. 6:37 That is changing with the advent now of, you know, commission-free trading. You can buy just very small pieces of a, uh, of a por- you know, as you're designing your portfolio. 6:46 Uh, there's things like fractional shares which have come out. So that benefit of that, uh, [clicks tongue] of the, you know, o- of using ETFs for small amounts has really... 6:54 It's evolving as we speak, and it's changed quite a bit over the last little while. So, you know, that's probably a, a benefit that is becoming less and less relevant. 7:02 But I still think today, depending on your personal circumstances, it might be a benefit. 7:06 The- another really key reason that you, um, might consider using ETFs, I think I spoke earlier about bells and whistles, and we're looking today at two very generic Plain Jane Canadian bank ETFs. 7:19 But there are, uh, strategies that you can overlay on top of these ETFs. 7:24 And so whether it's a covered call strategy, whether it's maybe a leveraged strategy in a split share corporation, um, whether you wanna have maybe a broader exposure, so including those insurance companies, uh, that is a reason that you might prefer to go with an ETF, um, over just a strict, uh, portfolio of individual securities. 7:43 Again, personal choice. Uh, the big con, I think, of having an ETF, or one of the biggest cons, is the fees. Now, mutual fun- or sorry, ETF fees have come down a lot in the last, uh, few years. 7:55 Uh, the fees, particularly on the, the funds I'm looking at here today, on ZEB, the management fee or the management expense ratio is 0.28%. On RBNK, it's 0.32%. And for many people, that's not an issue. 8:08 Uh, some people are very, very focused on fees, and you could make a strong argument if you're gonna own, you know, that ZEB with... You have the six banks equally weighted. 8:17 If you just go out and buy those yourself, yes, you'll... Well, you might get them commission-free, today's environment, or even if you did pay a commission, it's a one-time deal. 8:24 You let those ride, and it's not an, an annual recurring fee. Uh, so you could make an argument for that. [upbeat music] Hey, everybody, it's Brandon here. 8:36 I'd like to interrupt today's episode very briefly to remind you that if you're looking for more training in the Canadian stock market, don't hesitate to check out our Investing Academy. 8:45 You can join our private membership group and get access to our top stock picks, trade calls, portfolio insights, and a variety of tools that are helping our members all across the country better their own investing journeys. 8:57 All it takes is one great stock idea or tip, and that alone can cover years and years of your subscription to our membership group. 9:04 If you're looking for some additional video training to broaden your knowledge and expand your understanding of the stock market in Canada, we do of course offer a fully video online training program where you can learn from the comfort of your home amongst a variety of students across the country. 9:19 Both of these products can be found at www.theinvestingacademy.ca where you can sign up for them online or schedule a call with us to learn more. Now back to our scheduled episode. 9:32 Uh, but we're going to talk more specifically about owning individual securities, uh, now and that, you know, there's some, there's some upside to that but there's also some downsides. 9:41 So, um, just to wrap that up, if you're buying individual securities, the- one of the big pros is that you, you don't have to pay those fees to, um, on an ongoing basis. As 9:50 small as those fees are in the big scheme of things, um, that's a benefit there. 9:54 Now, you may agree or you might disagree with, uh, this next advantage, if you will, to buying individual securities, but it's the advantage of managing the portfolio or of picking the stocks or of, of adjusting and rebalancing according to your, uh, objectives. 10:11 There's this, you know, this alpha debate where i- if you, you know, can you actually add value by monitoring things and making trade calls, uh, to, to add above and beyond what the index itself would be able to bring you? 10:24 The debate will never be solved. It, it'll always be there. Uh, you can have, make very strong arguments on both sides. 10:31 A lot of it depends on your experience, um, how, how much time, as I mentioned earlier, you have to put into your, into your stock picking, uh, exercise. So but that is an advantage. 10:41 If you are in the camp that, uh, that you feel you have the, uh, skills to do that, well, then that's something that can give you a little bit of an advantage, um, to using individual securities. 10:51 Another very strong reason is just because you love doing it. It is very, very common because people love investing and even when I was working as an advisor, I had clients who would come into meetings with... 11:02 They, they'd done their own research. They weren't just relying on me to manage portfolios. They just liked learning. They liked learning. They liked owning or knowing about the companies that they owned. 11:11 That was very important to them. So they would be more leaning towards buying individual securities than ETFs just 'cause the- they love it. 11:19 They enjoy what they're doing there and, again, in many cases, um, client or investors will use that to gain experience, to broaden their depth of managing the portfolio in the first place. 11:30 So that's another thing that, that, uh, really might play into swinging, swinging the, uh, the pendulum in the favor of owning individual securities. A more minor benefit I think is, uh, you do get voting rights. 11:42 With an ETF, you don't have voting rights. Uh, you lose those. 11:46 If you are, you know, more involved in the [clicks tongue] in the, the exercise of voting for your- the companies that you own, well, if you own the individual securities, um, you have that right to do that. 11:57 I, I found over the years unless you're 11:59 a, unless you're a major investor or are very, very passionate about the companies that you're buying, uh, probably most people don't exercise those options but i- it is there if you have it. 12:07 A really, really important advantage in my opinion to owning individual banks versus the ETFs is just the fact that you can be more strategic with managing your portfolio and, uh, an example I'm gonna give, uh, here is that you can target riskThat you wouldn't be able to have, um, if you own the ETFs in general. 12:27 And when you look at the banking sector, there are a lot of risks that, that come with owning banks. 12:33 And if we look at this table here, we're going to see a, a recent survey that shows, you know, the top risks, but three that jump out at me are the geopolitical risk, the credit risk and the housing market risk. 12:45 And if you have the inclination to take your, your, uh, research, your due diligence to that next level, uh, having individual securities will essentially allow you to, I would say, map your holdings to very specific risks. 12:59 And we can think of, you know, housing risks. Uh, there's c- there's, uh, certain, uh, banks that are more, uh, they're, they're bigger in lending, for example, to the energy sector. 13:09 If you-- if your analysis has shown you that the... 13:12 you know, maybe you have some concerns about the en- energy sector and the viability of certain companies, well, you may want to shift away from a bank that is more exposed in that section there. You, uh... 13:22 every annual report, every, um, quarterly report that the banks put out, you'll be looking at their loan exposure and that's another factor that you might wanna, you know, put into play. 13:32 Uh, a big one also might be just geopolitical risk, as we looked at in the previous, uh, table there. Some banks have more exposure to, for example, Latin America, um, or Asian markets or, you know, the US market. 13:44 Whatever market it is that you either like or don't like, um, that you can, uh, tailor the portfolio more specifically so that balance can be more in line with what your views are there. 13:55 Also, it would allow you, if you have, for some reason you want to exclude certain banks, um, you may just hate a certain bank or you may be worried about a certain bank and just don't want to have them in the portfolio. 14:07 Well, with individual securities, you can choose to own four of the banks or three of the banks or five and just leave the, the sixth one out. It's entirely up to you, but you have the flexibility. 14:16 Clearly, if you're, if you're in a, a ZEB equal weighted portfolio, you don't have the flexibility to be able to do that. So there are benefits to doing it that way. But that comes with, I guess, risks or more work. 14:29 Uh, you need to do the monitoring. You need to do the rebalancing yourself. It's, um, you know, something that with the exchange-traded fund, they do that for you. Uh, so there's sort of those pros and the, the... 14:40 and there's cons along with that. So that's kind of up to you to decide what suits you best. Now importantly, because we all invest to grow wealth, uh, the performance, uh, how do these stack up against each other? 14:51 Which have performed better? So let's take a look at that now. 14:54 And on the first chart that I'm gonna put up on the screen here, we're gonna look at a five-year return, and you'll notice that there's quite a range of the individual securities. 15:02 So in this particular time period, the total return for Bank of Nova Scotia is at the bottom end around twenty-two percent, all the way up to eighty-two, almost eighty-three percent for National Bank. 15:12 Importantly, for what we're doing here, we'll note that ZEB falls somewhere in the middle at fifty-four percent, and we'll notice that RBNK falls, uh, closer to the bottom at about forty-one percent. 15:23 There's about a, a sixty-point gap from the worst performing up to the top performing. So those... 15:28 the ETFs, this is what I pointed out earlier, they only own the banks but they own them in different proportions, and those proportions change as time goes by for RBNK just because if the yields change, that's the index that it's based upon. 15:41 So we can see how, in this case and more specifically, that, that, uh, the adjustments that they made worked out to their disadvantage in this particular f- timeframe. 15:51 If we shorten the timeframe to the last three years, we'll see similar numbers where we'll still see Bank of Nova Scotia trailing with a thirty-four percent return, National Bank up at seventy-seven percent, but that gap has narrowed to forty, uh, four points roughly, and then we will see ZEB and RBNK interestingly here right in the middle of the pack. 16:11 And it doesn't shock me because in both cases you're getting a representation. You might say an average. It's not mathematically exactly an average. 16:19 Uh, but you're, you're going to expect in a shorter term, uh, as the six banks themselves have that divergence in returns, you would expect to see the ETFs sort of somewhat of an average of that and be more to the middle, especially on those shorter term basis. 16:33 What I like to always look at when I'm comparing companies like this or investments like this is look at the volatility on an annual basis or whatever the time period is. 16:40 In this case, I'm gonna show you a chart that looks at annual basis and there's really... I would say there's no difference here. If you look at, you know, the, uh... 16:47 if it's a positive year, a positive time period, in this case it is annual, you're gonna see all of these investments, whether they're individual securities or ETFs going up. 16:55 If it's a negative, for the most part, you're gonna see everything go down. So when you're making your decision, I don't think you really need to factor in too much the, the volatility on a shorter time period basis. 17:06 I, I think that's pretty much gonna be a wash in most cases just to a different degree of variability there. 17:12 Um, dividends, this is something that I find very interesting and, uh, I wanna maybe ask for your, uh, for your help on this one. 17:19 When we look at the dividend yields, uh, the banks are known for relatively strong dividends and, uh, current yields right now on the individual securities we're gonna see starting with a high of four point three three with, uh, BNS at the top of that and down to, uh, Royal Bank paying a dividend yield currently of about three point two three percent. 17:37 The yields on the ETFs are lower even though they are representative of the banks. ZEB is currently paying a yield of two point nine and RBNK with a yield of two point eight seven percent. I find this interesting. 17:51 You would think in theory at least that the yield [chuckles] would be, uh, of the ETFs would be a sort of an average of the holdings and in all cases right now, the banks themselves are paying a higher yield than the, the ETFs. 18:06 And, um, I don't know why that is. If any of you know why that is, uh, I, I don't think there's any fees that are associated specifically, uh, with the payment of the dividends, that type of thing. 18:16 So maybe, um, maybe that could be an explanation, but if you know that, then that would be, uh... I'd really appreciate you sh- educating me and sharing that with the community as well. On that note, what do you prefer? 18:27 If you are an investor today that invests in the banks, uh, do you use ETFs? Do you use individual securities? Possibly you may use a combination of the, of the two. 18:37 Please share that with the, with the community here and maybe your logic behind it and which-- what is your preference and, uh, we will all grow as a community. Um, that's gonna wrap up this video. 18:46 As always, I will make a mention that the first link below this video is for our investing academy and I would invite you to, uh, have a look there, explore what we have to offer from our training programs, and I will just say a big thank you for watching the video and I look forward to seeing you in the next video.