Transcript 0:01 Welcome to the podcast today. Just a quick heads up, this video is related to, uh, Canadian bank earnings. 0:08 It is very, very number intensive, so I will put a link here in the description so you can go and watch this on YouTube if you'd like to see the graphics that go along with it. If not, just enjoy the podcast. 0:20 So we have these rising provisions for bad loans, which we saw across nearly all of the big banks with the last earnings report. This makes me wonder, are we seeing the early signs of financial stress? 0:30 Are these banks just simply preparing for a rainy day and being prudent? 0:35 In this video today, I'm gonna recap how the big six banks, and for the first time, I'm also gonna include Equitable Bank in this due to popular demand, uh, during Q3 2024. 0:45 I'm also gonna look at some of the major trends that investors and businesses should be watching. Uh, first off, I wanna start with an overview of the sector. 0:52 So when you look at all the Q3 2024 earnings, the Canadian banking sector generally showed pretty good resilience, and this comes despite some ongoing economic challenges that we'll talk a little bit more about here today. 1:04 A number of the banks, I think of National Bank, Royal Bank come to mind, they posted pretty strong revenue, profit growth. 1:10 Um, all that said, in the quarter, we also saw something that might be a little bit concerning, this rising provisions for credit losses across nearly all of the major banks. 1:19 Uh, that is, um-- it, it's a reflection perhaps of some growing concerns over loan defaults as we are seeing these continuing high interest rates. 1:26 They are coming down, but they're still high relative to what we've seen in the last little while. Uh, also the economic pressures that affect, uh, borrowers are coming into play here. 1:35 Uh, some good news across, uh, the banks from a capitalization perspective for these-- the tier one, uh, ratio, most of the banks maintained or slightly improved their capital positions. 1:44 That shows that they re-remain, uh, well-capitalized and stable, and that is a reflection across the entire sector. 1:50 Now, I wanna look at some of the specific challenges now that are facing the sector, and I wanna start off with the big one, and that is the rising provisions that we're seeing for credit losses. 1:58 Um, one of the most consistent things that I noticed when I was looking, uh, across the earnings reports and across the entire sector is this increase in provisions for credit losses. 2:08 We look at banks in particular, I'll single out BMO, uh, and Scotiabank. We've seen pretty material jumps in the amount that they've set aside to cover bad loans. This could be a signal of potential future risks. 2:18 I mean, it-it's, it's a, it's a provision, so they're not on the books yet. Uh, they particularly commented on the commercial and consumer lending spaces. That's something that we need to keep an eye on. 2:28 So as I mentioned, I think the, the high interest rate environment that we're in right now is making it more difficult for borrowers to actually meet their obligations, particularly they highlighted sectors like trucking, commercial real estate, and auto loans. 2:41 When we look at this issue of economic uncertainty, this definitely has continued to, uh, weigh o-on the sector. It could be the interest rates, it could be the inflationary pressures that we're still seeing. 2:51 Uh, banks are definitely preparing for that potential slowdown in economic growth. Uh, we could see that put a further strain on their loan books. 2:59 We did see institutions like TD and CIBC, they showed good, solid core performance over the last quarter, but their forward-looking outlooks, uh, certainly reflect some caution due to external, uh, pressures. 3:11 We'll get to that as we go through each of the banks individually here. We also saw regulatory challenges, and TD Bank in particular here, they faced and continue to face, uh, significant regulatory challenges. 3:22 That came out in the Q3 earnings as well, related to the anti-money laundering issues that they're having in their US operations. We will look at that in some more detail when we cover them in particular here. 3:32 Now, another thread I saw through the earnings reports were strains in the loan growth and mortgage market segments. 3:38 We saw mortgage and commercial loan growth remain, uh, some of the key drivers for most of the Canadian banks. 3:43 But with the interest rate environment that we're in right now, this is putting some pressure on these segments. We did see banks like Equitable Bank here. They w-- They have a large mortgage and commercial loan focus. 3:53 They did in fact continue to grow, uh, despite these challenges here. Uh, lastly, Scotiabank, they indicated some stress in the variable rate mortgage portfolios, although, uh, it did highlight signs of stabilization. 4:05 So now I wanna go through and look at each of the banks one by one. I'm gonna order them by market cap, starting largest order, go through to smallest, uh, just so I'm not showing any favor to any particular banks. 4:15 But I wanna start off with the biggest of the Canadian banks, RBC. They posted pretty solid earnings growth. They had revenue boosted, uh, by its acquisition of HSBC Bank. That was completed earlier in the year. 4:26 RBC saw broad-based gains across personal banking and wealth management. But like you'll see as a common thread here, those credit loss provisions did increase. Let's look at some earnings metrics here. 4:37 Earnings per share were $3.09. That is up 13.2 cents from last year. Revenue booked in at $14.63 billion. That's a 12.7% gain. 4:48 Profit, four point four nine billion, up 16.3% from the three point eight six billion last year. So pretty strong numbers there. 4:55 Their provision for credit loss, and probably because I'm gonna be saying this a lot during this video, I'm gonna use PCL for that term. It came in at, uh, six hundred and fifty-nine million. 5:03 That's up 7%, uh, from last year, so not a huge jump for Royal. Uh, their CET1 ratio, 13%, up just marginally from the 12.8 they saw last quarter. So a very solid, uh, capitalization there. 5:17 Now, their growth, notably in this report, was supported, like I say, by that acquisition of HSBC Bank Canada division, uh, which boosted their net income by $239 million. 5:28 The increase in PCLs, that does show that the bank is concerned. They're being cautious about, uh, some possible loan defaults that might be coming on the horizon there. 5:36 However, when I take this, um, in, in aggregate here, the overall strength that they saw in their core operations definitely remains a positive sign. 5:43 Now, the second largest bank in Canada, Toronto-Dominion Bank, and we're gonna talk a lot about their problems here, but TD Bank's earnings were affected significantly by that one-time charge that we'll get to here related to the US anti-money laundering, uh, issues that they're dealing with. 5:58 But, um, the good news is, I guess, their core business operations outperformed expectationsEven with the setback, our revenue growth across core banking, uh, outperformed. 6:09 The metrics on their earnings, we saw earnings per share at two point zero five. That's down almost two percent, one point nine percent from last year. 6:16 Revenue of fourteen point two four billion, that's actually up four point nine percent from last year. Provision for credit losses, one point zero seven billion. 6:24 Now, that's up a staggering forty percent, thirty-nine point seven percent from the seven hundred and sixty-six billion do-dollars that we saw last year. 6:31 Their capitalization CET1 ratio, fifteen point five percent, up marginally from last quarter. So let's sort of talk about the elephant in the room here. 6:40 And TD is facing these fines that are linked to investigations regarding their US, uh, Bank Secrecy Act and their anti-money laundering program. They did record a provision here. 6:50 Catch this, two point six billion dollars US. 6:52 So that's equivalent of almost three point six billion dollars Canadian, and they booked that in the third quarter, uh, to, to account for those investigations into their AML program. 7:02 This includes both civil and criminal investigations that are being pursued by the US regulators. And remember, in Q2, they also took a six hundred and fifteen million dollar provision that was related to this matter. 7:13 So that brings the total charges related to these AML issues they're dealing with to around three point zero five billion dollars. 7:20 If we can put that aside just for the moment, I know a lot of people can't, but if we can, if we look at the underlying business, it appears to remain pretty strong. 7:27 With the core banking operations, they were showing growth. This regulatory issue, though, it does remain a material risk factor when you're looking at the bank, especially for their, um, near-term performance. 7:38 So factor that in when you're making your investment decisions. Now, the third bank, Bank of Nova Scotia, they had, uh, mixed results in Q3. 7:46 They had profits that were declining, due mostly to the provisions, uh, for bad loans. But we also saw some signs of stabilization in consumer credit stress, and particularly in auto loans and in variable rate mortgages. 7:59 If we look at their metrics, their earnings per share came in at a dollar forty-one. That's down seventeen point one percent from last year. 8:06 Revenue, though, eight point three six billion, that's up three point six percent. Profit was one point nine one billion, again, down. 8:13 That was down almost thirteen percent, twelve point eight percent from the two point one billion dollars they saw last year. Now, PCLs, one point zero five billion. 8:22 Again, that is up, uh, twenty-eight point two percent from only eight hundred and nineteen million, um, last year. 8:28 Capitalization, their CET1 ratio is thirteen point three percent, up very slim at zero point one percent from the thirteen point two percent last quarter. 8:37 So as you can see with Scotiabank here, like most of the banks, they did increase those provisions for credit losses, and that indicates that some loan defaults continue to weigh on their profitability. 8:47 But it looks like they've stabilized a certain types of loan portfolios. Auto loans, they stipulate, and that suggests that maybe, in their case, the worst of this consumer stress, uh, may be easing. 8:57 We can take that as a positive sign. Um, also, revenue growth, uh, shows that the bank is performing well, but that credit risk remains a key factor that we have to monitor. 9:06 Next bank, Bank of Montreal, they had earnings that were under pressure this quarter, and they were due to these rising provisions for bad loans, which in their case nearly doubled compared to the previous year. 9:17 They saw modest revenue growth, but it wasn't enough to offset the concerns over increasing loan provisions, e-especially in sectors they identified as commercial loans and trucking. Look at their metrics. 9:27 Their earnings per share came in at two dollars and sixty-four cents, down ten percent from a year ago. 9:32 Revenues of eight point one nine billion, they were up marginally, one point seven percent from the eight point zero five billion last year. They showed a profit of one point eight seven billion dollars. 9:42 So that was up a healthy nineteen percent, uh, year over year. 9:46 From a provisions for credit loss perspective, catch this, nine hundred and six million dollars, up eighty-four percent, uh, from the four hundred and ninety-two million dollars that they booked this time a year ago. 9:56 Uh, ratio, thirteen point zero percent, down very, very minimally, the zero point one percent from the thirteen point one percent last quarter. 10:04 So clearly, uh, of the banks that, uh, reported this quarter, BMO seems to be facing these challenges with credit losses in its commercial loan book, especially in these industries that are affected, uh, more by interest rates and the economic uncertainty that we may be facing here. 10:19 Uh, we did see slight revenue growth, but the bank's loan loss provisions do raise, uh, some concerns, particularly as its exposure to these particular sectors seems to be growing. 10:28 Now, number five on the list, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, CIBC. They reported, uh, improved earnings, and largely this was due to a sharp, get this, reduction in their provisions for bad loans. 10:39 That's something that the only bank that we saw in this quarter here. That came alongside strong performance in both their personal and business banking. 10:46 Some segments, though, they, they highlighted, um, capital markets. We did see some weakness there. The metrics on CIBC, earnings per share came in at a dollar eighty-two cents. 10:56 That is up twenty-three point eight percent from last year. Revenue, six point six billion dollars, up twelve point eight percent from the five point eight five billion we saw last year. 11:05 Profit, one point eight billion, up a healthy twenty-six, almost twenty-seven percent, uh, from one point four three billion dollars last year. Their PCL number came in at four hundred and eighty-three million. 11:16 Now, that is down thirty-four point four percent from the seven hundred and thirty-six million that they booked last year. 11:22 And their CET1 ratio, thirteen point three percent, holding steady, up marginally zero point two percent from the last quarter. Now, we saw CIBC put in this pretty strong performance here. 11:32 That was driven by these reduced credit loss provisions. Also, we saw growth in their personal and banking sectors there as well. 11:39 But the capital markets division did see some challenges, and a lot of the bank's future growth, they all-- all the big banks rely on that capital markets revenue. 11:48 Uh, we could see, uh, some challenges there as they manage volatility in that space.Six, National Bank of Canada. Uh, they delivered strong earnings growth this year. 11:58 They outperformed analyst expectations, and you can see in this report how the bank's diversified operations across their personal banking, their wealth management, financial markets all contributed to this strong performance. 12:09 Um, this came despite the fact that they did increase, like most of the other banks, their PCLs. 12:13 The metrics for this bank, earnings per share, two dollars and sixty-eight cents, up twenty-two point nine percent, almost twenty-three percent from last year. 12:21 Revenue came in at three billion dollars, up twenty percent, uh, from the two point four nine billion dollars last year. 12:27 They showed a profit of one point zero three billion, up a very healthy twenty-four point one percent year-over-year. Their provisions for credit loss is a hundred and forty-nine million dollars. 12:36 That is up thirty-four point two percent from last year. Capitalization, they have a CET1 ratio of thirteen point five percent. That is no change from the previous quarter. 12:45 So as I mentioned, uh, National Bank did show growth across personal commercial banking, wealth management, and financial markets. 12:52 Their increased PCLs, this does reflect, like the other banks, a growing risk in its loan book. 12:57 And this, uh, sort of despite the fact that the bank is-- looks like it's pre-- run, run pretty well overall, the numbers are positive. 13:04 Uh, the rising provisions, though, do indicate possible caution that you should be exercising in the near future. 13:09 Now, for the bank you've all been waiting for, especially those people who comment every time I do one of these bank updates, EQB, Equitable Bank. We're gonna talk about them right now. 13:17 They showed very solid earnings growth, led by an increase in loan volumes and net interest income. The bank here, it does continue to show some strength in its core mortgage and commercial lending operations as well. 13:28 They showed earnings per share of two dollars and sixty-seven percent. That's up eighteen percent from the previous year. 13:33 Revenue came in at two hundred and seventy-five million, up twelve percent, uh, from two forty-five million last year. They showed a profit of a hundred and nine million dollars, up a respectable twenty percent as well. 13:45 For a provision from credit loss perspective, they booked fifteen million. That's up twenty-five percent from the twelve million dollars that they had booked, uh, last year. 13:54 CET1 ratio, fourteen point two percent, up zero point three percent from last quarter. 13:59 So we can see here that their growth was driven, uh, by an increase in mortgage lending and net interest income, and that comes despite this rising provision, uh, for credit losses. 14:09 In particular here, the bank's focus on the core mortgage commercial lending operations. This has allowed it to perform well in this challenging market. So there you go. All in all, not a bad quarter for most banks. 14:20 Should you own a bank stock or should you own an ETF that holds banks? Here's a video right here that's gonna answer that question for you. As always, thank you so much for watching. We'll see you in the next video.