Transcript 0:00 This podcast is brought to you by our friends at BMO ETFs. Please stay tuned for important information at the conclusion of this episode. We all have limited cash flow. 0:12 Some of us have more than others, but, uh, nobody has a unlimited number. At least, you know, average people don't. Yeah, maybe some. A couple people. 0:19 What we're gonna talk about this video today is when you have that cash flow and you're trying to decide where to allocate it, and you've got a couple things. You've got an investment program, and you got a mortgage. Mm. 0:28 A lot of people are in those situations. Where do you take that money? What is the biggest bang for the buck? Do you pay down the mortgage more aggressively, or do you put that money into, uh, an investment program? 0:38 And there's, there's pros and cons to both, and we're gonna cover those off today, basically. And I know this is a thing that just impacts so many people out there. I see it in the comments. 0:45 I've been asked this question before. Yeah, yeah. And why I think this is a timely video, Dad, is just this past week I made a decision for my situation- Mm... on what I wanna do. Mm-hmm. 0:53 And in fact, I was thinking we could use that as somewhat of a case study. Share some numbers, you know, rough numbers. Doesn't have to be exact. Yeah. 0:59 But give you an idea of my situation, and you can maybe provide your thoughts. Absolutely. Some over- like look over, uh, yeah, we'll- Timing couldn't be better... look at this and our decision. 1:06 [laughs] Timing couldn't be better. And I happen to be here, uh, in the Vancouver area. Good to see you. We're having a joint video. 1:10 We don't get to do this very often, uh, so this is really special to be able to do this, so. Really special. And hey, hopefully it's a really valuable video. Yeah. So let us know down below. 1:17 To set the context, some of my numbers, my situation, I've talked about this on the channel before, so some of you guys w- will know this. When I took on my mortgage for my townhouse- Right... 1:25 when rates were much lower- Yeah... I am on a variable rate, I was paying about $3,500 a month. Yeah. The rate at the time was 1.45%. I might be a little bit off, but let's just say roughly, right? 1:35 And just in case you're wondering where Brandon lives, it's clearly either Toronto, Vancouver, or Montreal because $3,500 a month, uh, at, for a townhouse at 1.45%, yeah, it's, we, you know, the Vancouver area. Yeah. 1:47 So it's, it's possible. Not Manitoba. We don't live in Manitoba. [laughs] Although we will be going there next month. Uh, in a few weeks we're going there. Yeah. A few weeks. Going back to the- Yeah... back to the roots. 1:53 Yes. Um, but no. So yes, this is Vancouver. The home prices, as you guys know, is just ridiculous. Yeah. Case in point being was that my mortgage was right at that 3.5K a month. 2:03 We know the story with how interest rates have acted over the past couple of years. Um- Yeah... big, big climb. We are starting to see that come down. I think it's three quarters in a row now, if I'm not sure. Excuse me. 2:11 Three 25 basis point cuts by the Bank of Canada. Three basis point. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. And at one point at the peak, my mortgage had gone up to about $7,000 a month. So think about that. 2:21 Like- That's when you stopped paying me the allowance, I think. [laughs] Exactly. Well, that's when it, that's when I had to tighten up. 2:25 [laughs] For those that have been following for a couple years, like I decided to allocate, you know- Yeah... for my investments money that I would typically put in. 2:30 I said, "Listen, at this rate I need to pay down the mortgage first." That's priority number one. Mm. And my investments did take, uh, you know, a, a hit. A pause. A pause. Yeah. Let's call it that way. Yeah. 2:40 Well, I'd say happily from my standpoint is now that rates have come down, that has freed up some capital. As of today, it's sitting at about 2... 5.25%. So down from 5.95 at the peak. Correct. Yeah. 2:51 So that doesn't sound like much, but on a bigger loan amount, that frees up a pretty significant chunk of capital for me. Mm. And then again, bringing us back to the topic of the video is what to do. 2:59 And before we dive into that, Dad, and the considerations, one thing that I thought was very valuable for s- those in this situation is running through like a mortgage calculator. There's essentially a calculator online. 3:09 It's a free one that says like, "Pay down debt or invest?" I think that's the title of the calculator. And you can go in, punch in your specific details. Mm-hmm. 3:15 Uh, even things like your marginal tax rate if you're investing outside of a RSP, TFSA, whatever it is. Yeah, yeah. Um, to help get you to like a break even number, like the math behind what makes more sense. 3:24 I did a video two years ago- Yeah... which I think was very, um, I think prudent to forecast this. 3:30 Well, you're supposed to do this, and I remember sitting down with you, and you're, you were able to secure a mortgage at 1.45%. Mm-hmm. So we ran through some projections. Okay, let's just be, get a little bit crazy. 3:42 Let's say that goes up to 4.5%. Yeah. I mean, probably won't, but let's say. Or worst case scenario, let's say 7%. Interest rates go up that high. 3:50 And it's funny, it doesn't sound like a worst case scenario now looking at it. [laughs] But back a couple years ago when rates were at one, you know, 2%, that did seem quite far-fetched. Yeah, yeah. 3:58 But it was, you know, the proper prudent thing to do to forecast those, let's just call it three scenarios. Yeah, yeah. Right? Just in case. And in reality, that's what ended up happening to me. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. 4:08 And I'm just, I'm glad I did that because it... Those are the types of things you have to account for. Um- I- I mean, in hindsight, obviously fixed would've been an amazing choice. 4:14 Well, I think the, the key there is why you do these stress tests is if this worst case scenario happens, can I afford to carry the mortgage? That, that's why you go through the whole process, right? Exactly. Yeah. 4:26 And in my case, again, I'm gracious I could. Is it fine? Is it, uh, great? No. But it is something that we planned and forecast for. But it took some of that limited cash flow away from your investments. Certainly. Yeah. 4:36 Well, now we fast forward to where we are today. We have a bit of cash flow that I've essentially gained back, if you will. What do I do with that? Mm-hmm. Do I invest that? 4:44 And on the topic of investing, I wanna stop, uh, this video for a, a quick word from our sponsor. Imagine that you're planning for your future. You're balancing the need for growth, the desire for steady cash flow. 4:54 Maybe you're thinking about retiring early or funding your child's education. The BMO Balanced ETF could be the solution that you're looking for. 5:02 It is a carefully crafted mix of global equities, fixed income ETFs from BMO Global Asset Management. They're designed to help you grow your wealth while at the same time managing risk. 5:12 What's more, the fund automatically rebalances every quarter to keep your investment strategy on track even when the markets shift. 5:18 You're not just investing in a portfolio, you're investing in peace of mind knowing that your money is managed by a name that you can trust. 5:24 Explore how the BMO Balanced ETF, the ticker is ZBAL, can fit into your life and help you reach your goals. Visit BMO ETFs today to find out more. All right, welcome back to the video. 5:34 So the question at hand here is how do you approach the situation? Mm. From what I've seen, there's so many ways to approach this. 5:42 In fact, leave a comment down below if you're in this situation and either you're thinking about doing something, maybe you have made some changes- Have you changed your approach to this? Similar, yeah. 5:48 Has that changed over the years? Or maybe some experiences. Mm. Because interestingly, you know, I made a post over on Blossomdad, and we got a variety of different opinions. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Very different opinions. 5:57 Mm-hmm. There's a ton of posts that were-You know, for paying down that mortgage first. Yep. I think a lot, right? That is priority number one. A lot of them. Yeah, yeah. 6:05 "Here's five months left on my mortgage," um, "paying off the mortgage all day long for me. I finished paying my mortgage at the turn of the year. What an amazing feeling. No regrets allocating so much when I did." 6:15 Here's someone actually taking money from their investments, paying down a lump sum. Hmm. They can't wait to be mortgage-free. A lot of these I assume, 6:22 um, come down to is it a peace of mind thing, is it a mathematical thing? Well, some of it, there's intangibles. 6:26 You can crunch the numbers till the cows come home and say, "This is financially, using proper estimates, the best thing to do." But one of the things that I felt 6:35 a lot when I was working with clients, and this decision came up a lot, was the emotional side of it or how much stress. And some people just absolutely hate carrying debt. 6:45 Even a really good, prudent mortgage, for some people it just- Weighs on them... it weighs on them, yes. Hmm. And so they do prioritize, um, that. Some people just like to be debt-free. Understandable. 6:57 I would say, though, there's two components to this. And, you know, you're in this. You're 29 years old, you're building for a future. You also wanna pay off the debt. 7:03 So you can use this Dave Ramsey theory, "I'm just gonna put all of my money, all of my free cashflow to paying down that debt, and defer essentially building the asset." 7:14 Well, the problem is, as you know, I mean, one of the first things you learn when you're becoming an investor is the, one of the most important assets you have is time. And so that compounds over years. 7:23 And so if you have, you know, heck, let's say you go this, you take a sort of traditional 25-year mortgage, and now you're 50, that's late. That's pretty late. 7:31 That's a late start to the party if you wanna get your investment portfolio going. 7:33 Well, you only have then theoretically, you know, if you wanna retire at 60 or 65, a decade or so to build that while you've sacrificed a doubling of couple times along the way. So it come... 7:44 Like, one of the things, your age would have a big impact on this. Hmm. Absolutely. 7:48 If you're 50 or 45 now, you have nothing saved up already, interest rates are coming down, I would say it might make sense to start being more aggressive with the investment program. 7:57 If you're younger, yeah, maybe lean it the other way. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, th- I actually just wanted to highlight an interesting one. This, this is one that, that I thought was, uh... 8:07 It was actually the top comment here. I think it was from Jason. 8:09 He said, "I'll be mortgage-free when I sell my current expensive house in BC and buy a cheaper but same size house in a lower cost of living province, Alberta, in the spring. 8:17 I'll invest the leftover equity in stock, ETFs, real estate," da, da, da, da, da. Uh, "Can't wait to be mortgage-free," or, oh, "Can't wait to miss the, miss the BC weather," da, da, da. 8:26 [laughs] This is a situation I guess where this person, you know, maybe I guess if you have a plan to one day downsize- Yeah... maybe then it favors you more to paying down that mortgage first. Mm-hmm. 8:38 Just knowing that that's gonna be kinda your exit plan. This is a perfect example. Keyword is plan. And a lot of people don't think that far ahead. Mm-hmm. 8:44 But with, with Jason here, he's got clearly a plan on what, maybe he's got family. Oh, he's saying Alberta here. Mm-hmm. 8:50 Uh, go now before the price goes up too high there, 'cause that's one of the most rapidly rising real estate markets [laughs] in Canada right now I believe. Hmm. But, um, I like the concept here. 8:58 Uh, I live in a smaller community, and a lot of people move from the city exactly as they sell an asset, they move, they sell their home, move and buy something at half the price, you know, the same quality of life. 9:09 In fact- Ah, yeah, I'd do that... [laughs] well, the same quality of life for a smaller town for an older guy. I think you'd probably think the city's a little bit more exciting, more restaurant choices. 9:18 Point there is I think, I don't know this, but I, you know, talk to a lot of my neighbors. We live in a pretty nice neighborhood. Yeah. 9:25 There's a lot of people who have lived there for many, many years who the house value has gone up. Yeah. But based on the, my conversations, I don't think they have a ton of cashflow. Right. 9:33 So they may have prioritized- That's a big thing with the bo- with the boomer, not to n- n- not, not to say a bad word, but the boomer generation. Yeah. Um, that's like a, very, quite a common thing. 9:43 There's one of the sort of an old saying I guess, but yeah, if you, if you just focus on the mortgage, you don't have your investments, you know, okay, you're retired now, great value in your house. 9:52 How do you tap into that? I wanna go on vacation. Yeah. And you gotta sell a window, sell a door, a staircase. Like, no, you can't do that. You can tap in maybe through a r- you know, a, a HELOC. 10:00 You can sell and downsize. I guess I'm just gonna say, I don't know where we're going on next with this, Brandon, but to me, this is a, the quintessential you wanna balance it off. 10:08 You wanna have, you know, some different objectives and simultaneously hope- ho- hopefully, uh, run them. But back to your situation. [laughs] Well, yeah, I mean, I t- I guess we can transition on to I guess my- mine. 10:19 Hmm. Yeah. Um, th- there were two major considerations that I, I factored in, one being the returns, which we've talked about. Yeah. 10:25 But actually, l- like, like, I guess, and correct me if I'm wrong here, Dan, in my logic, but you know, when, when rates were at let's say 7.2- Mm-hmm... uh, prime rate that is- The, the mortgage... 10:34 yeah, sorry, the prime rate. My mortgage was a little bit less- Right... 'cause it was about minus 1.25. Mm-hmm. But when the prime rate was up at about 7%, 10:43 I felt a lot more comfortable paying down that mortgage, taking the guaranteed return, because realistically I, I do see a world where, you know, my investment portfolio earns that. Yeah. 10:52 But it's not necessarily, it's not quite a guarantee. You know what I mean? 10:55 [laughs] I mean, in fact, y- yeah, you can look at the data and say, "This is what we'd expect over a decade or over the course of a couple decades" But there is value when rates were let's call it higher, I mean, again, we're talking like relative to today- Yeah... 11:05 when they were higher, and the highest I've ever seen in my lifetime- Yeah... being aware of this stuff. Um, 11:11 even if it was like a pretty even match, I, I, I w- I prefer paying down that mortgage, taking the guaranteed return. And- Like, from a mathematical standpoint. Yeah. 11:18 Again, not to say that we can't outperform that in the market, you could, but there's that uncertainty aspect. And that to me from a return standpoint, I was happy paying down the mortgage. 11:27 That's kind of the trade-off there. And keep in mind, if you're paying, say, 7% of your, five, 6% of your mortgage, that's after tax dollars. Hmm. Right? So the rate of return has to be higher. 11:36 Taking that guaranteed return, I think when int- when the mortgage rates are that high, um, yeah, it skews it in, in that direction. Yeah. As opposed to when you started at 1.45%. 11:46 Then it's in the opposite, completely opposite direction. It skews it in the opposite direction. It's the completely opposite direction. One other thing to factor in here too is you have assets already. 11:51 You're not starting from scratch. Yeah. So you already have, you paused the program. Correct. True. Right? And so that makes a big difference as well, or can make a difference. 11:58 And yeah, like, I mean, I don't wanna be over dramatic and say like, "Oh, rates have come down so much" They've come down a little bit. They've come down 75 basis points. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. 12:05 But that is inching more and more in favor of having that balance going back again, right? And I guess m- my logic is-Do I think I can outperform this in the stock market? 12:14 Probably a very similar return even at today's rates. But mo- what was more important to me personally, Dad, and again, this is a personal situation- Mm-hmm... was actually, like, the diversification aspect- Mm-hmm. 12:23 Yeah... from, from my, from my net worth, right? Mm-hmm. And again, you make the decision that's right for you. 12:27 But being in Vancouver and with the home, home prices being, you know, where they are, you know, I, I had to put a pretty good chunk down for a down payment. Like- Right... 12:35 you know, my equity in my homes are significantly higher. I'd say probably I have three times more equity in my home- Than-... than I do in my investment portfolio. Than your RSPs, TFSAs. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. 12:44 Which is, again, just the nature of it. And again, that, that, that's worked well for people. I, I don't think that's wrong. Like you said, maybe a lot of people made their wealth i- in real estate like that- Mm-hmm... 12:53 over the years. But for me, I just... I, I feel more comfortable having my, my, my net worth a little more balanced. Yeah. I think so. 13:01 Which is, again, a big reason why I'm like, "Okay, I'm actually happy to allocate a bit more money here." And I don't wanna say even it out, I don't know if that's gonna be the case, but more- Gen- generally. Yeah... 13:11 actual. Yeah. And again, I, I, I'm... I've only been in the housing market for, what? A few years now. Right. Um, you know, be- becoming, becoming an adult and buying a home, whatever. 13:19 You know, the, the, the, the prices here in Van- in Richmond and Vancouver have done so well. Like, I don't know if that's always gonna be the case. 13:25 There, there could be a world where, you know, this market tanks or something happens. There will be ebbs and flows, for sure. Ups and downs. Yeah, ebbs and flows, yeah. 13:31 But, like, just, just to protect myself from that, to mitigate from that, that potential is I don't wanna have all my assets in one market, right? And in partic- right now, all my stuff is in one market, technically. 13:40 Mm-hmm. Like, one city. Um, so- Yeah... so to me, it's a big, I, I guess, a peace of mind thing to say I actually don't mind having a bit of both. 13:47 And then, like you said, being able, of course, to tap into that cashflow- Yeah... is, is a huge thing as well. Um, one other thing that just comes to mind, Brandon, as well, if... 13:54 in this debate whether investing or not, and you're making that decision, I don't think it'll affect you because you have been investing for a long time and you understand the ups and downs of the market. 14:03 But you would also probably, possibly wanna consider where we are in the market cycle right now. Mm-hmm. In the equity market. 14:10 And we're, you know, we're touching all-time highs every week it seems we're going more and more. Mm-hmm. So does that mean that there's an element of risk of the markets could correct? Mm-hmm. 14:19 I mean, we know at some point they will. It was gonna happen now or, you know, a year or two or three. Um, absolutely. 14:24 If you're a new investor, that might be scary as well, but also you're doing a monthly plan which, you know, going back to the dollar cost averaging, and if the markets drop, you're still, still gonna keep doing it. 14:34 Uh, so... But that's something you wanna consider if the markets were, you know, at, at seemingly lows- In my favor... even more am I skewed in favor of, of putting more money into the markets. That's a good point. 14:44 That a- that wasn't actually the biggest consideration for me. And again, I know you're not suggesting timing the market. Yeah. That's not the point. Yeah. Um, but that was less of a consideration for me- Mm-hmm... 14:52 in this, in this scenario. Yeah. Um, but yeah, I guess th- th- yeah, that's just, like, an update on what, on what, what, what I decided to do. Mm-hmm. And I'm curious, like, leave a comment down below. 15:01 What, what did you guys decide to do or, or do you agree with what I'm doing? Yeah, I think the, the message for this video is, like, it's so personal. Like, it's so situational. 15:10 Like you said, things like age, you know, where your assets are. Do you have a pension? All these things come into play, right? Can I give an old guy, retired financial advisor cynical... 15:20 Please don't say this is the way to do it. Yeah. Because the whole point of this is there isn't the way to do it. Yeah. There's... It all comes down to your circumstances. 15:27 Maybe, yeah, if you leave a comment and say, "This is what we chose because of our circumstances"- Yeah... yeah, that's, that's what it's all about really. [laughs] Yeah. And, like, at the end of the day, I... 15:35 what I always say when it comes to, like, the real estate side of things is that you can make the mathematical choice, like the, the dollars- Yeah... and cents choice. Uh-huh. 15:42 But you touched on it earlier, there's so many other variables that, that may even outweigh that for your personal situation. Yeah. Um, again, all that to say, like, it does feel, 15:54 it does feel like a late start if you're, if you're gonna go entirely mortgage first, and then start your investments in your 50s. That, to me, that, that does seem a little... I, I don't know if I wanna say wrong. 16:05 I think it's crazy myself. You do? Y- y- yeah. Just- Well, yeah, 'cause I'm sure there's people that, that do that. Yeah. I just- Crazy people... 16:11 uh, well, and one of the things, anytime you're doing these plans, a very, very disciplined person would say, "Okay, I'm paying my mortgage. 16:17 When it's gone, I'm gonna al- take all that money and start putting it into investments." That's what the calculation would be, even then it's off to a late start. Reality is- People are gonna-... 16:25 oh, maybe I've paid the mortgage and I'm gonna spend money on this dream holiday. I'm gonna do this. Mm-hmm. And before you know it- Mm-hmm... you... 16:31 that, you know, months or years have gone by where you didn't start that program and the math has all gone to hell then, so. True. Yeah. [laughs] That's true. That... yeah, that's true. You used the term diversification. 16:41 Stocks, bonds, you know, equities, growth, et cetera, and real estate generally is, is a pretty good formula. Yeah. Yeah. No doubt. Well, hey, um, let us know what you guys think down in the comment section below. 16:53 Um, very curious to, to hear the opinions and situations you guys find yourself in. Yeah. Um, and yeah, I'll certainly keep you guys updated too, uh, with what I'm doing. 17:04 But that's just, like, literally this w- past week I made a change. I'm like, "This could be worth the video." I think it's, I think it's a good topic. Yeah. Yeah. Good. Well, if you guys enjoyed, give it a thumbs up. 17:12 Um, subscribe. Yeah, don't forget to subscribe. Definitely. Very important. And have yourselves a great day. This content is intended for information purposes only. 17:23 This content has been prepared by Beavis Wealth and represents its assessment at the time of publication. Beavis Wealth is compensated under this arrangement by BMO Exchange Traded Funds. 17:31 The content contained herein does not necessarily represent the views of BMO Global Asset Management. The views expressed herein by Beavis Wealth are subject to change without notice. 17:39 The content contained herein is not and should not be construed as investment advice to any party. 17:43 Any securities described herein must be evaluated relative to the individual's investment objectives and risk tolerance, and professional advice should be obtained with respect to the individual's particular circumstances. 17:53 The views expressed herein by Beavis Wealth regarding a particular company, security, industry, or market sector should not be considered as an indication of trading intent of any investment funds managed by BMO Global Asset Management. 18:04 Any reference to a particular company is for illustrative purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell, nor should it be considered as an indication of how the portfolio of any investment fund managed by BMO Global Asset Management is or will be invested. 18:19 This social media network is an independent organization and is not affiliated with BMO Global Asset Management. BMO Global Asset Management is a brand name under which BMO Asset Management Inc. and BMO Investments Inc. 18:29 operate.