Transcript 0:00 Welcome to the Beavis Wealth podcast. I am excited today to be joined by Adam Bourne from Parallel Wealth. And Adam is a retirement planning expert right here in Canada. 0:09 If you've ever searched for retirement advice on YouTube, I'm sure you've come across his channel. 0:14 He has built a great platform that's dedicated to helping Canadians make key financial decisions as they transition into retirement. 0:21 In this episode, we're gonna be answering questions that were submitted by viewers of my YouTube channel retirement series, Second Act. 0:27 This is a 12-part series designed to help Canadians build a retirement plan that works for them. We have episodes one and two live now. 0:35 Episode three is coming out very shortly, and new episodes will be released every month on the Beavis Wealth YouTube channel. 0:42 If you haven't already, be sure to check out the playlist so you can follow along with the full series. Now let's get into our questions. Adam, welcome back to the podcast. How are you? Really good. 0:52 Thanks for having me again. Look forward to this. Yeah, you bet. No, it's nice. We got good reception on the first, uh, podcast we did, so here we're number two. We're back. [laughs] We got... Yeah. We got rehired. 1:02 We made ep- we made episode two, so. Yeah, exactly. As long as people keep asking questions, we'll keep answering them, so. Yeah, so let's go right to those questions. 1:11 And, um, I wanna start off with a question by Rick, Adam, this time around. And very good question here, a lot-- probably applicable to a lot of people. 1:19 He says, "In a situation where my wife was paying into an RRSP for around fifteen years, recently she got a job where she is paying into a pension, and the employer matches, and she's still contributing to the RRSP. 1:33 So given that in retirement her income will be higher than we originally planned due to the pension income, I'm not sure if we should still continue to contribute to the RRSP or start up a TFSA for her instead and focus on building that." 1:46 One of the things that sticks out to me, I'll get your thoughts on this in a second, but one that sticks out to me, and I don't know whether you feel it's relevant or not, but what stuck out at me is he didn't say whether it's a... 1:55 Like, there's two types of, of pension plans: defined benefit and defi-defined contribution, and he didn't stipulate which one of those was, and I'm wondering if maybe... 2:05 To me, that probably makes a difference in what the answer would be, but what are your thoughts on that, um, Adam? Yeah. 2:10 It sounds like a defined contribution, just because he puts, "And employer matches," so I'm gonna guess it's a defined contribution based on that language, but you never know. 2:19 Um, and it, it might, might make a difference, it might not. Um, I think, like, given the retirement, her income will be higher than we originally planned. 2:29 You know, should we basically shuffle our personal savings from RRSP to TFSA? Uh, typically not still. 2:35 Um, a-and if you look at, you know, when you're putting money in while you're still working, you have to look at your marginal tax rate. 2:41 So, you know, if she makes $80,000 a year and she does her work, you know, defined, let's say defined contribution pension plan now, if she's still at 60, 65, it might still make sense for her to do an RRSP because come retirement, there's income splitting. 2:55 She'll probably be in a lower tax bracket. 2:57 So I think there's two parts of this, uh, Mark, that I would look at is, is A, can she put more money or can she put money in today at a higher tax rate than what she'll pull it out in retirement? 3:09 The money is growing tax-deferred. That's all obviously beneficial. The other part of it is should she start building up her TFSA? Well, that's also a good thing to have in retirement, right? So it's, um, you know... 3:20 You wanna have a funded TFSA in retirement, for sure. 3:23 So I would say to Rick, like, if you guys are getting close to retirement and you don't have a TFSA, yeah, maybe start allocating some of that RSP money over to the TFSA. But typically, I wouldn't say stop the RRSP, 3:39 right? And this is maybe where time to sit down with a planner and figure out, like, where this, this line draws. Well, and the other thing here that I'm looking at too is it depends, like, is she 35? 3:49 Which is possible if she started work at age 20, worked for 15 years, and now she's 35. Or is she 60? Uh- Exactly... you know, or... That, that would make a big difference because... 3:58 And the other thing that I would say would be necessary, uh, for Rick to look at here is the size of the current RRSP. 4:05 We're kinda, you know, gonna assume it's a f- you know, a normal average rate of return, but if it's done very poorly or done very well, that could also factor in it as well. Yeah. 4:13 I was just gonna say, and if, if this is more of a promotion for her, then, you know, what, what accounts does Rick have? Like, maybe we start putting money into a spousal RRSP. 4:22 Like, if you're retiring before 65, and you need to look at income splitting, like, there's more layers here. Um- Mm-hmm... this is where, you know, planning off a little bit of information can be tough sometimes. 4:34 But I think from a general higher level, I would say, you know, I'd probably keep plugging away at the RRSP, um, make sure we fund some of the TFSA for retirement. 4:43 But just because she has a work plan doesn't mean that, you know, the rest of the RRSP should drop off. 4:49 I, you know, I tend to agree i-if we had to just make the assumptions that we've made, and I think back when I worked with clients, um, you know, many clients had, like, especially a defined contribution plan, and they still were building up their RRSPs as well. 5:02 So I think that's... Given the information we have, Adam, I think that's probably the best we can do. Yep, absolutely. Good. Well, next question here. 5:11 The username on this, I don't know how to pronounce this, you can help me, MN1337HX. How would you pronounce this? That's my English too, yeah. [laughs] Yeah. So this, this person knows who they are. 5:23 But the question is this: "I'm considering retirement at some point. Currently have about 550,000 invested in my RRSP. 5:31 The current portfolio generates almost 12% of income from various dividend-based investments, including some harvest ETFs. Um, coupled with CPP and OAS, I'm generating $85,000 per year before tax." 5:45 It goes on to say, "I have zero debt and tend to stay in my house as long as I can. My question is, when do I start the drawdown if my portfolio is generating enough income already? 5:55 I haven't seen many videos that use this method. I always see the drawdown method being used, which I understand. However, if I did that, I wouldn't have enough to last me in my no-go phase." So that's the question. 6:07 A lot of moving parts to that one as, as well. What's your first take on that, Adam?Yeah. So, uh, I mean, we come across this a lot. Um, 6:17 I, I think where this person maybe has gone wrong is, you know, I won't have enough in my no-go phase, but really the drawdown is, is more of a tax planning play, and it's not an income play. Right. 6:26 So just because we're pulling money out of your RRIF doesn't mean that we're spending that money. Mm. We're actually, a lot of times, moving that money from your RRIF account to the TFSA. 6:35 If that's maxed out, to a non-registered account. So it's just reallocation of funds to create more tax planning. 6:41 It's not we need to draw it down to, you know, burn it away and spend it in the go-go phase and forget about my no-go phase. So it- it's... 6:48 I think that's where there's a bit of a disconnect and, you know, the RSP drawdown or meltdown, whatever you wanna call it, is really a tax planning play. It's not an income play, it's a tax planning play. 6:59 So if we need to draw it down more aggressively, it's just topping up TFSA and non-reg. 7:03 Well, and, and a couple of things w- come to my mind is a lot of people think that if you take money out, you have to spend it, right? And you know, a very common thing I would do with clients is- Yeah... 7:13 you know, Ja- f- first of January, w- we would take part of their initial re- mandatory RRIF withdrawal and move it straight into their TFSA. That would fund their TFSA. 7:23 So like you say, they're not going, "Oh, I've got, you know, 7,000 bucks, I've gotta go buy something." It's just more allocating. 7:29 Now, I guess one of his concerns here, I suppose, is he's already generating $85,000, seems to be all in his RRSP. That it would be actually given that money. Yeah. So yeah, I don't th- it would... 7:40 It's, it's kind of two different things that he's, that you're looking at here. I tend to agree with you that the strategy of, like, why do you take money out of your RSP before you need it? 7:50 Uh, like you say, it's a tax play, right? Yeah. 7:52 Like, if it, if he keeps doing what he's doing or she keeps doing what she's doing, um, at the end of the day, there's gonna be $550,000, you know, assuming the nav stays the same. Oh. They're drawing everything out. 8:03 Yeah. You know, over half a million dollars sitting in your RSP when you pass away. A- and that's a tax problem. Yeah. So we need to spread that out over many years to kinda level out that tax bill. So, um... 8:15 And, and it's, we've seen this a lot with, you know, these higher yielding, uh, funds or products that, "Well, I can just live off the interest." And that's great- Mm... 8:23 but y- you do bump into a bit of a tax issue down the road. Yeah. Another, again, is it says here, uh, retiring at some point. 8:31 I, I take that to mean relatively soon, but if some point is, you know, 20 years down the road, I might change into the equation here, but let's assume that some point means, you know, in the not too distant future. 8:42 [laughs] Well, and if they're not retired, um, you know, what is their income now? 8:46 Like, maybe they wanna start draw- Like, if they're worried about this, we've had some clients actually start drawing down some RSP before they retire. It's rare. 8:53 Um, but again, this is, you know, hate to keep pointing back to go get a plan, but you know, get a plan in place because there is some nuance to that. Well, and this, this is, to me again, appreciate the question. 9:04 It is the perfect example of, you know, when you look at these questions, there are so many pieces that have to be factored in that it's never quite as simple as, you know, you, you'd like it to be on the face. 9:15 I, I just recorded a video on that of like, you know, here's this, h- here's kind of a something that everyone should do in a plan, but it only works if you also do this and this, right? Right. 9:24 You can't look at things in silo when you come to retirement. And th- in this case, she's looking at the 12% of income in a silo. Like, "That's enough for me, so I'm gonna, like, put my RSP aside." 9:33 And, and that's, you know- But what about-... probably gonna bite her in the- Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Gonna bite her later on with taxes. I mean, Siri loves it, but y- she won't or he won't. Yeah. Yeah. Very good. Okay. 9:45 The next question here comes from DL. I can pronounce that, no problem. Uh, DL says, "What is the difference in estate taxes between having your spouse as a successor annuitant versus a beneficiary? 9:58 Uh, are there estate or personal for living spouse tax pros and cons to these two different designations?" Um, I'm assuming that this person is talking about a tax-free savings account here. Is that what you're assuming? 10:11 I would assume so. Yeah. Be- because the successor annuitant, I think, is pretty specific to that. A beneficiary can be in other types of accounts as well. But the TFSA- Yeah... um, has both. 10:23 Is there anything we might be missing on this? So yeah. What is the difference in estate taxes? Um, I mean, the only difference would be obviously successor annuitant. 10:32 You know, i- if you and your spouse have both maxed out your TFSA and one of you pass away, the other basically just takes it over. 10:38 Like in simple terms, they get it, so they don't need the contribution room to take on your TFSA. Mm. A beneficiary, that can still happen, but there's a few extra forms to, to fill out. 10:49 And there, if there's growth between time of death and transfer of TFSA to yourself, uh, there will be a bit of a tax due in the estate. So when you talk about estate taxes, there's no reason that... 11:03 Maybe you know one, Mark, but in my head, I, I've never come across a reason why you would not name your spouse or common-law partner as a successor annuitant, um, in Canada. Y- y- yeah, I, I agree with that. 11:15 I mean, there are some machinations I'm sure that someone could dream up, but, um, I don't... Maybe if there's a... 11:21 I don't know if there's an, a, a pending divorce or something like that that's already started, that might be a reason. Haven't thought that one through. But I do... 11:28 You know, having gone through this, it can take a long time for these estates to be settled, depending on how complicated they are, even something as seemingly simple as, as moving an RSP over. 11:40 Um, thinking of some cases that took longer than they should have. So that, the element that you mentioned where any growth between the time of death till the actual transfer's completed would be taxable. 11:52 Whereas with an annuit- uh, with the successor, then that's all taken care of. It all just- Yeah... becomes part of the bigger RSP. Yeah. You may not name your, your spouse or partners. 12:02 You know, if it's a second marriage and you're leaving that money to kids or like, th- that's where it would maybe land where you wouldn't name a successor. 12:08 But again, like, like with registered accounts, there's a big benefit to-Pass that money tax-free. Pass the RRSP to your spouse versus cashing it out at death. 12:19 So, um, that's where some good estate planning comes into play of if you're in a second marriage or something like that, um, th- there's better ways and worse ways to pass assets on to who you want. 12:30 Um, so just make sure you understand, like, what's taxable, what's not, what tax... You know, what could be passed in a more tax efficient way. Um- Mm-hmm... I see it done very poorly quite often. 12:41 I think the default, Adam, and you probably would agree with this, I'm just gonna guess, the default is things are done poorly because, you know, people just don't know what they're supposed to do, and without professional guidance, they just kind of do the best they can. 12:55 But, uh, you know, I'm guessing, now correct me if I'm wrong here, but I'm... 12:59 I can't imagine how many countless plans you've created, but there's probably very few that you put the plan together and you go, "Wow, this is exactly the way... 13:08 You know, you've done this perfectly, and there's nothing I can think of that would help you create, you know, more wealth or save taxes, et cetera." Never. Maybe some, but certainly not many, right? Uh, like, never. 13:19 In fact, we go to the point where, like, when someone hires our team to do a plan, I always tell them, like, "Look, if we don't save you your money a few times over, give you... 13:26 Like, if you don't walk away with this saying, 'Hey, that was well worth it,' like, I'll give your money back." And, you know- Right. Yeah... I've... We've never had to over many, many years. So, um- Yeah... yeah. 13:35 But if the estate planning is much like the retirement plan, like people, you know... I'm on my second, third marriage. Things are complicated. But I don't wanna pay $1,500 for a lawyer. I'd rather just save that money. 13:46 Mm-hmm. Same with a plan. Like, people enter retirement, it's like, "I'll just wing it." It's like, man, y- y- most people are wasting, you know, $100,000 plus to wing it. 13:54 Um, so when it comes to these things, like, if your estate is a bit more complicated, if you're, you know... I- i- in my opinion, any type of retire- like, anyone retiring should have a proper plan. 14:04 It, it's gonna be worth, you know, worth your time and money to invest in something like that up front to get clear direction on it. Sure. So that's... Especially with this. Like, should you have successor beneficiary? 14:14 Well, it, it might be a little bit dependent but, you know, sit down with a lawyer or even your financial planner and get some feedback on it. Yeah. 14:21 And also, again, I think I've mentioned this earlier, but it does remind me once again, it's just how many pieces of the puzzle there are here. 14:30 And, uh, you know, I'm, I'm in the process right now of, um, building a workbench for my, my, you know, a table bench for my garage 'cause I'm becoming a handyman now that I'm partially retired here. 14:43 And, um, uh, you know, you watch a few YouTube videos and you say, "What a great idea. That's perfect." But then you watch another video and you go, "Oh, but if I do that, I can't do that." 14:51 And i- just, like, there's never an end to it, right? [laughs] Right. It's the same, same thing here. 14:56 You can start withdrawing from here, but it affects you over there, so, uh- You could hire a carpenter, and in about one hour he'll have it built. Yeah, I know. But, you know, I love... Here, here's the thing. Okay. 15:06 I'm all ears. I love the proc- I love the process of building it, and I'm not gonna... It's not gonna change my retirement if I buy a few extra pieces. [laughs] Well, that's the thing, right? 15:12 And, and that's where some people have an opinion that's like, "Well, I'll just figure it out." 15:16 It's like, okay, but that is costing you a lot of money where, yeah, where, you know, doing a workbench yourself isn't changing much, uh, financially for you. I mean- Right... 15:22 just watch your thumbs on the saw and you're good, but. I did a... Yeah, exactly. I did a video a long time ago, uh, and it was just about the value, uh... 15:31 It was, you know, should you hire an investment advisor if I just recently retired? And, you know, the... I started the video by saying there was a time where my, my dishwasher broke, and I needed to fix the... 15:41 It wasn't rotating. So I went online, and I figured out, you know, how to do it, and I gave it a try, and it worked. No big deal. But there was something else. 15:51 Another example, like, if there was, like, if I needed to replace my gas furnace, you know, I can go online, probably see a lot of videos on how to do that, but I'm not gonna take that chance. 16:00 It's just too costly if I, if I get it wrong, right? So. Yeah. Exactly, yeah. I mean- And it always sounds bad coming from us. Like, "Hey, we're a financial planner and you need us," right? But- Yeah... 16:09 uh, like, hundreds of people every year come in through our office getting plans, and they walk away and it's like, "Wow," like, "why doesn't everyone do this?" It's like... I- Yeah. Yeah. 16:18 I had the- What could you do wrong? I had the same experience. And yeah, you know, it's a good point, and I, I don't want us to come across here like we're trying to sell anybody anything. Yeah. 16:25 We're just trying to give good, solid advice and- Yeah... you know, some recommendations as to what people can do and, and, you know, that's just the way... That's the best we can do, right? Yeah. 16:33 Okay, uh, question number four. And on this video we just had the four questions, so this will be our final question for this video to- or for this podcast today. Um, I think the pronunciation is Weng- Wengu Kai. 16:47 I'm gonna guess Wengu Kai. You will know who you are. The question is, "Thanks for the information. Much appreciated. 16:53 Is a spousal RRSP still important if the higher income spouse can split his RRIF income to the lower income spouse later?" And I think that's a great question. I go way back when, you know, spousal RRSPs... The, the... 17:09 I think I go back before there was even the, you know, the age 65 income splitting or maybe there was a tiny little bit. Uh, spousal RRSPs were one of the premium [laughs] tools that a, that a couple could use. 17:20 But certainly the rules have changed over the time. So my sort of take on this question is that, um, it's, again, comes down to circumstances. 17:28 A spousal RSP is probably, I'm gonna say, less important than it was before, but I still think it is important, and maybe you can educate me here. 17:38 I mean, I have a spousal RSP, uh, for my wife, and, uh, you're still using it and expect at some point we'll benefit from that. But so what are your... what's your- Yeah... take on, on that question, Adam? 17:50 I think, like, we see spousal RSPs rarely nowadays. I, I think- Mm... a big part of it actually is, is, you know, back in the day, in let's call it the '90s, um, you had a lot of one income households. Yeah. 18:03 Where nowadays that's really rare. Um, so you have two income households. Both people are contributing to the RSP. They kind of ramp up to retirement in a more equal position. Mm-hmm. But any time there's a bit... 18:16 So two reasons why you'd want to look at an RSP. Uh, if you plan to retire before 65-And you have unequal accounts, that you wanna make sure that you have that tax flexibility. Um, so that would be one thing. Yeah. 18:29 And yeah, if you have one... Yeah, like a single income- Oh, sorry. Yeah, go ahead. Sorry to interrupt. I'll just add because you have to be 65 or older to split that income, and a lot of... 18:37 You know, some people might not, uh, be aware. I'm assuming that's what you're, uh, alluding to. Correct, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, unless you have a defined benefit pension plan. 18:43 But even then, you probably wanna have a spousal just to create some flexibility. 18:48 If you need to draw more RSP and only that higher income-earning spouse has a defined benefit plan and the RSP, and the spouse has nothing, that can create a bit of a lopsided tax situation. 18:59 So yeah, retiring before 65 without the, uh, pure ability to, to split 50/50 on that, um, or if you have one, like, a lot higher income-earning spouse than the other. Like, my wife doesn't work. Um- Mm-hmm... 19:14 so like- Outside of the home. Out- out- outside the home. She helps with the YouTube stuff. [laughs] So she technically has an income. Like, she, she does help. 19:20 She works, you know, e- enough to get a bit of an income here. But in general, my income's a lot higher than hers. Right. So yeah, we have four kids. Yeah, she definitely works harder than I do. 19:28 [laughs] But, um, hey, that's for another podcast. But so I... We actually utilize an, a spousal RSP, 'cause I plan to retire before 65, um, and my income's a lot higher. 19:38 So I, I just wanna make sure, like, when I plan ahead for my own plan, I look and say, "We may need it, we may not, but there's no harm in building it up now." 19:46 So to answer the question, is spousal RSP still important if the higher income spouse can split his RRIF? Yes, he can split his RRIF at 65 plus. So as long as you guys aren't retiring before 65, you may not need it. 19:59 I, I just... I don't see a harm in having it. If a lower income spouse is planning to retire earlier, I mean, in this day and age, we see age gaps in, in, in, uh, relationships as well. Mm-hmm. 20:12 Um, yeah, I guess, I guess I'm just thinking it probably relates back to the 65 question, and if you're... A lot of people don't... 20:18 You know, if you're in the FIRE movement, for example, you, you don't wanna wait till you're 65- Yeah... to be financially independent, so. 20:25 Yeah, just always remember with the spousal RSP, there's the, uh, the attribution rule, right? Yeah. 20:29 So if you start y- building up a spousal RSP, you know, uh, basically the year you put it in, the two years following, you can't touch it. Um- Yeah... 20:37 you can convert it to a RRIF, take out the minimum amount, and that won't be attributed back to the contributor. But- Mm... 20:44 just general terms, make sure you wait that, the year plus two, uh, before you start pulling it out, or else your kinda tax planning solution i- is wiped out. 20:53 Um, yeah, that's, uh, that's something a lot of people d- aren't aware of. 20:56 And I just, yeah, just sort of reminiscing here, I guess, going back to your, your earlier statement where, I guess, you know, back in the day, the typical family is the husband worked, the wife raised the kids. 21:08 You know, Dad had all of the assets for the most part, and then the spousal RSP made sense. Is, it's probably less so today as- Yeah... as we've evolved as a society, I suppose. Exactly. Yeah. 21:19 A- and I think that's why, like, I would say 10% of people that come in our door will have a spousal RSP. I think it's- Mm... 'cause they both work. They've, they've both built up RSPs. 21:28 And, and people are retiring later nowadays too, and that comes into play as well. Like, back in the day, people were retiring at 55, 60, 'cause they had a defined benefit plan. And, you know- Mm-hmm... 21:38 n- nowadays, people are working well into their 60s, well into their 70s, some of them. So, um, you know, that, that negates the, the need for a spousal RSP as well. That's so funny we're seeing both ends, right? 21:48 Some people are working longer, others are working... are, are trying to retire younger. 21:53 And, uh, my experience was, you know, everybody sort of targets that, you know, traditionally 65, and I don't think I had any clients who retired on their 65th birthday. 22:02 [laughs] It was either, "I love what I do, I'm gonna keep going," or, "I hate what I do, and I'm gonna..." Or not even that, but, "I just, I wanna get out earlier." But rarely was it actually 65. Have you... 22:11 Has that been your experience too? [laughs] I, I could picture one client that retired on their 65th birthday. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's, it's very rare. 22:18 Uh, typically people, it's, it's, you know, "I get a bonus if I work to this date," or, you know- Yes... 22:23 a lot of people will work to end of year to their, you know, their last day is actually January 1st or 2nd, so that... 22:28 Because a lot of people will get, especially if you're government or big corp, you might get a bit of a severance or, you know, your, your payout of holiday pay or vacation pay or whatever, right? Yeah. So- Yeah... 22:37 um, yeah, rarely does it fall on a birthday. Yeah. Yeah. That's been my experience too, but. Yeah. Well, good. Well, Adam, uh, yeah, nice, nice to chat with you again. 22:46 And, uh, th- just earlier today actually filmed video three, episode three in this series. And so, um, look forward to having that out at some point next week. 22:57 And so I guess, uh, you know, couple of weeks after that I'll gather up the questions we get from that. If you're listening to this podcast, then, uh, go ahead with the... 23:04 You'll watch the YouTube channel, Beavis Wealth, and the next video will come out next week, answer your question. 23:10 And if you've learned anything from this episode today, give us as much detail as you can without, you know, giving away who you are [laughs] or anything you don't feel comfortable with, because these things can be a little bit complicated. 23:21 Yeah, exactly. Well, thanks for having me, Mark. Look forward to the next one. Well, that is a wrap for today's episode. Again, I wanna just send out a huge thanks to Adam Bourne for joining me, sharing his expertise. 23:31 If you do want more insights on retirement planning, be sure to check out his YouTube channel. It's called Parallel Wealth. He's got a lot of valuable content on there to help you make more informed decisions. 23:42 If you are looking for a structured step-by-step approach to planning for your retirement, don't forget to visit our Beavis Wealth YouTube channel and check out the playlist, Second Act, a 12-part series on retiring in Canada. 23:54 Thanks as always for tuning in. We'll see you in the next episode.