Transcript 0:00 What is going on you guys? And welcome back to the video. Today, we're gonna be talking about Wealthsimple Plus and answering the question: When is it worth paying for the subscription? 0:08 Is it worth paying subs-paying for the subscription? What is the math behind this? And I'll tell you, there's some very fascinating findings that I have uncovered that I'm very excited to share with you. 0:19 It's not as simple as you may think. But, uh, yeah, a lot of you guys are familiar with Wealthsimple Plus already. If you aren't, here's a thing right from their website. 0:28 "For a measly ten dollars per month, you can buy and sell all the U.S. stocks you want with no commissions, no foreign exchange fees. 0:35 We're thrilled to announce this, uh, Plus feature," ba-da-da-da, you get a bunch of new features, which is a USD account, no foreign exchange fees, unlimited price change alerts, and instant deposits up to five thousand dollars. 0:47 Essentially, my takeaway from this is that, uh, what you are paying for is a U.S. dollar account. 0:53 Now, to clarify, just for those very beginners on Wealthsimple, Wealthsimple is a commission-free platform, meaning you don't pay a little percentage when you buy and sell stocks, but there can be a Forex conversion fee, a currency conversion fee, when you go out and buy U.S. 1:11 securities. So no commissions, but U.S. stocks, you can incur, in fact you do incur, a one point five percent currency conversion fee. 1:20 Just to clarify what I mean by that, if I go out and buy, you know, Telus stock, which is obviously a Canadian stock. I buy Telus stock, I pay zero percent in commissions, I pay zero percent in currency conversion fees. 1:31 If I sell Telus stock, zero. You do all you want. It's a-- that's a great, great, uh, perk to this platform. 1:38 However, at this point, if you were to go out and buy shares of Google, I know the ticker for Google is not G, but Google is obviously an American stock. 1:47 It trades on the, the NASDAQ, I believe it is, or the New York Stock Exchange. It doesn't trade on the TSX. 1:52 You actually have to pay a one point five percent conversion fee to essentially take your Canadian dollars, convert them into U.S. dollars, to therefore go buy this on the exchange. 2:00 If you went and sold Google stock, well then you'd pay another one point five percent fee on the way out, essentially bringing your total costs, if you will, again not in commissions, but in currency conversion fees, to three percent. 2:13 Now, this Wealthsimple Plus feature says for ten dollars a month, you can bypass that. And I mean, that's a pretty fascinating, um, you know, thing. Uh, very interesting. 2:23 I know a lot of our viewers probably do subscribe to Wealthsimple Plus. We're gonna go through some math in just a second. But I'll pop up on the screen, this is what it looks like by the way. 2:31 I really wanted to test this out. I haven't used Plus in the past, uh, but I, you know, did their little trial just to make sure. You literally get both accounts. 2:39 So as you can see with my, you know, personal account, you have your Canadian dollar account, and you essentially have a second account, which is strictly a U.S. dollar account. 2:47 If you had a TFSA, you'd have a Canadian TFSA and a U.S. TFSA. If you had RSP, R-- yadi, yadi, yada. Now, very important that I'd like to, uh, point out here, this is actually critical in our decisions. 2:58 If you do subscribe to Wealthsimple Plus and you essentially unlock this U.S. dollar trading account, you still have to pay an initial conversion to get your Canadian dollars into the U.S. dollar account. 3:12 Let me say that again because it's very important. I deposit, let's say ten thousand dollars, you know, into my Wealthsimple account. I link it up to my TD, Royal Bank, whatever it is. 3:21 I have ten thousand dollars Canadian I wanna go put in this Wealthsimple. 3:25 I have to convert that ten thousand dollars to the USD account, which I've unlocked via Plus, but you do still pay the one point five percent on that initial conversion. Here's an exact slide by the way. Um, 3:38 you'll only pay the one point five exchange conversion fee when you convert, uh, initially convert to your account, but not each time that you trade. 3:47 Now, that may sound minimal, but it actually comes back into play quite a bit. An important call-out as well is that you cannot at this point directly deposit USD into the account. So for example, with Questrade, 4:00 if you have a U.S. dollar bank account, you can go U.S. dollars directly into the account as U.S. dollars. With Wealthsimple, you can't quite do that at this point. 4:09 You have to do that stepping stone where you go Canadian dollars into the account, one point five percent conversion fee into the U.S. dollar account. 4:16 It looks like on a personal account, uh, I'll put up a screen for you guys as well, it is available on taxable accounts, but not TFSAs and RSPs. 4:24 It says here, "USD deposits and withdrawals at this time are only available for personal DIY trading accounts." 4:31 Meaning if you invest with a TFSA and RSP, which I know is a lot of you guys, you do still have to do this stepping stone format, and you still get hit with this one point five percent fee. Now, why is that important? 4:42 Well, let's get to the meat of this video. 4:45 I was initially under the impression that for ten dollars a month, the, the, the simple math that you have to ask yourself if this is worth it is: Do I pay more than ten dollars a month in U.S., uh, conversion fees? 4:59 If I do, Plus is worth it. If I don't, Plus is not worth it. I stand corrected on that, and there's more math that comes into it because basically... 5:08 I hope this is on screen, but the math comes out to, I believe it's seven hundred and seventy-six dollars, something like that. If you took seven hundred and seventy-six dollars in trading volume in U.S. 5:18 stocks, you times that by one point five percent, uh, which is their, which is their fee, that would come out to about ten dollars. Do you get where I'm at right now? You guys can double-check my math there. 5:27 But essentially, if you trade over seven hundred and seventy-six dollars in a month, uh, in U.S. stocks, you would essentially pay ten dollars in fees. 5:33 Now, if you paid more than that, well then Plus is probably worth it. Not quite, and it's because of what I mentioned there about the initial conversion. So let's run through the math here a-and I'll explain exactly why. 5:46 Um, on this little gr-graph, I'm gonna put here our initial deposit, okay? So this is action number one. I'm gonna put, for example, buy when we buy our first stock. I'm gonna put here, let's say, sell. 6:00 Let's say we make a sell for a certain stock.And then I'm gonna put here withdraw, like literally taking money, you know, out of the account, i-if you will. 6:08 So let's assume I'm an investor who has ten thousand dollars and I wanna go buy shares of, uh, Google, okay? Google is obviously a US stock, but I have ten thousand dollars that I wanna invest in, um, in Google. 6:20 Well, on the basic tier, which is what everyone kind of standards off starts with, essentially when I deposit ten thousand dollars Canadian into my account, that's completely okay, right? 6:31 I can deposit ten thousand dollars and look at my account. I have ten thousand dollars Canadian. There's no fees, n-nothing because this is a Canadian dollar account. 6:38 Essentially, I incur zero percent fees on the initial deposit. With Plus, for example, if I were to then put in ten thousand dollars into my account, all allocated towards Google stock, 6:51 again, because you do have to pay that initial conversion fee to get it into US dollars, I actually pay a one point five percent conversion fee upfront, right, to get that into the account. 7:02 This is about a hundred and fifty dollars in our example, uh, in trading fees. All is good. Now we move on to our next action which is let's assume I wanna buy ten thousand dollars worth of Google stock. 7:13 Well, in the basic plan, I can take my ten thousand dollars, I can pay the one point five percent fee, which again is a hundred and fifty dollars in trading costs, whereas with Plus, I can buy this with zero, uh, forex conversion, zero currency conversions. 7:27 Obviously, this would be zero. That's great. If I were to sell Google stock, again, you get hit with the one point five percent fee, whereas Plus, you get the perk of paying no fees. 7:40 Now, what's interesting is that let's assume I wanted to withdraw this money. Uh, I, you know, made a good trade, whatever the case is. 7:48 I wanna take money out of, uh, Wealthsimple, hit it back to my bank account, go spend it wherever I want. 7:54 With the basic plan, you pay zero dollars, uh, or zero percent conversion fee, zero dollars to withdraw, uh, to essentially take your money out because again this is all Canadian dollars. 8:03 Whereas with the Plus, you actually do pay, you know, similar to that initial conversion fee where you're taking money, putting into this account, when you want to take money out of your USD account, well, you have to convert that back, and you are hit with a one point five percent fee 8:18 on the back end. Okay? 8:21 Now, in reality, this is a c-- you know, um, let's just put this like a bearish case scenario for Plus because you're probably not going to, you know, make a trade within a month and then wanna withdraw your money. 8:31 The goal is that you'd want to invest over the, you know, number and number and number of years. 8:35 But nevertheless, this is just a, you know, it indic-- it, it showcases it really well because what's fascinating about this is that the total fees you paid in this scenario is three percent or three hundred dollars. 8:47 The total fees you paid in this scenario is three percent or three hundred dollars. It's just the flow of where you pay it is jiggled around, right? In this one, you paid it upfront to convert. 8:59 This one, you paid it per trade. 9:01 Now, obviously the caveat to that is that if you make a lot of trades within these periods, like let's say you're doing a lot of buys and sells, well, on the basic plan, you're gonna be hit with a hundred fifty dollars, a hundred fifty dollars, a hundred fifty dollars, a hundred fifty dollars, whereas here you have the perk of free trading. 9:19 The point that I wanna illustrate with this is that I used to think it came down to a dollar figure like, "Hey, how much money am I gonna be buying in US stocks? If it's over this amount, this makes sense to me." 9:32 What I've come to realize is that it's not a dollar figure situation because as the dollar figures scale, you still have to pay this initially. You're still paying... 9:41 Even if it's a hundred thousand dollar trade, you're still paying that initial fee. It comes down to a frequency of trading. How frequently are you going to be buying and selling US stocks? 9:51 If you're a more frequent trader, absolutely this can make sense. If you're a less frequent trader like myself, let's say you're a buy and hold investor, right? So which I assume a lot of... 10:02 You know, actually I guess I shouldn't assume. 10:04 You know, you-- we may have swing traders that follow the channel and people that wanna be more active on Wealthsimple, but I know for a fact a lot of my, uh, trading, for example, if I buy Google, I don't plan to sell that for the next number of years. 10:15 It's almost like a one-time purchase. If I wanna allocate ten grand to Google or five grand or one grand, whatever it is, I buy it once, and I let it go, right? 10:23 Now what happens is even on the basic plan, even if I wanted to, let's say, dollar cost average or add, you know, every paycheck or every pay period I wanted to buy more Google shares, 10:35 let's assume I put another thousand dollars into the account. Again, Canadian dollars. I put, you know, a thousand dollars into my TFSA. 10:42 I still have to make this upfront conversion each and every time I go to purchase this. So the question I pose is, well, why not just leave it in Canadian dollars and then pay the one point five percent here? 10:52 That could in theory actually provide me more flexibility because I'm not like, you know, doing the math and, and converting money unnecessarily and then converting back. 11:01 I just have everything in Canadian and when I wanna purchase a, a, a stock, US stock, I pay the conversion fee. 11:07 And of course, you know, big point to this is that I would be saving, you know, ten dollars per month or a hundred and twenty dollars per year by not paying for this feature. 11:16 Uh, you know, I saw online people saying this was like a, a misrepresentation or it was like a sly marketing move by Wealthsimple. I don't know if that's... I'd go as far as saying that. 11:24 I don't think that they're like trying to, um, you know, misguide, uh, Canadian investors, but I do think it gets misunderstood wrong. You hear all these no currency conversion fees, no forex fees on trading. 11:36 That is true, but you do still have to pay the initial one, meaning you're still paying it and the flow is very different. I, I got a question. 11:43 Uh, actually one of my, you know, one of our students, Aaron, uh, who actually suggested I do this video, he did a bit of digging for me, um, which shout out to Aaron and the Investing Academy. 11:51 Of course, guys, if you're in the market for courses and training and you like learning about this type of stuff, anything to do with stock market as a complete beginner, check out the Investing Academy. 12:00 That's our program down below where we work withCanadians, every single province all over the place, uh, tons of awesome people. 12:07 But Aaron actually asked the question, "Well, if you are a dividend investor, does this come into play?" Which is a really, really good question, right? 12:13 If I'm gonna buy US stocks-- US dividend stocks versus Canadian dividend stocks, does this make more or less sense? He actually reached out to the chat for me and just wants to say, "I wanted to verify. 12:22 When I hold a US stock and it pays a dividend, do I have to pay a conversion fee?" So example, I own Johnson & Johnson, or I own Procter & Gamble. They pay me a dividend. Do I-- and I'm a basic member. 12:33 Do I have to pay this one point five percent additional fee to convert that back to Canadian dollars? Wealthsimple support says, "No, you would not need to pay a conversion fee on dividends." 12:44 Aaron said it gets transferred, uh, at the regular rate for the day, uh, into Ca- Canadian dollars. They say that is correct. 12:50 Unless you have a plus subscription, it means you would hold the USD and the US in a USD account, and the funds would be received in USD. Otherwise, the funds would be transferred back into, um, Canadian dollars. 13:02 Case in point being is that by being a Plus member, what that means is that your US dividends would come into the US dividend account. 13:07 If you weren't a Plus member, those dividends would be converted back to the Canadian dollar account, but they're not tacking on an additional fee. 13:14 Obviously, there'd be the Canadian US dollar exchange rate, obviously, but they're not tacking on additional fees every dividend you get. 13:20 Therefore, you know, the question was posed, well, does this give me a big advantage as a, um, you know, investor, a, a dividend investor? 13:29 Possibly not as much as you may think, um, just because i-it just depends on what currency you wanna get this, uh, you know, the dividends in. 13:37 Nevertheless, you know, I wanted to go through this math because I think it is a, um, a possibly enlight-enlightening, and a lot of people may have overlooked this. 13:47 I'm not trying to bash Wealthsimple Plus because if you are a frequent trader, I think this could be great, and I think for a lot of people, they have a lot of, um, you know, benefits to this subscription plan. 13:57 But I also think there's a lot of investors who paying this ten dollars a month may be unnecessary if they actually understand what's going on. 14:04 I think, um, long story short, if you're a buy and hold investor, you guys do your own research, make your own decision, but me, my, my conclusion is that if I'm a buy and hold investor, I'm pretty cool with the basic plan. 14:15 You know, I don't need to pay ten dollars a month to have this feature. I-if I'm just gonna be buying the occasional US stock, I'm happy to just pay those one-time conversion fees. 14:24 I would even argue possibly, you know, there are other platforms out there if you're gonna be a heavy US stock investor that you may wanna look at other than Wealthsimple Plus, Wealthsimple in general. 14:32 Um, if you are an investor who will frequently trade, and again, these little dots I indicate, this is where the money is saved. If you're gonna be jumping in and out, jumping in and out, well, then it makes sense. 14:41 Pay the initial conversion fee up front, do all your trading, sells, buys, do da da da da da. 14:46 And again, this is like a bearish case scenario 'cause it's unrealistic that you're gonna like sell your s-- you know, withdraw the entire account. I just wanted to kinda display it, um, so you get the full picture. 14:55 In that case, it's awesome. 14:56 And of course, um, if you are a, a Canadian investor, you only plan to buy Canadian stocks, Canadian ETFs, uh, CDRs for that matter, Canadian depository receipts, which are all Canadian products that trade on Canadian ex- Canadian exchanges, well, then you don't have to worry about it. 15:11 Definitely stay with the pl-- uh, the basic feature 'cause then you don't have to pay the ten dollars, and you can go do that. And you can still get great US exposure as a Canadian investor. 15:19 If you go out and buy VFV, for example, which is, uh, you know, the S&P five hundred ETF, that's still a Canadian-listed product. You still buy that in Canadian dollars. 15:26 A CDR, you go buy a Costco CDR, Canadian, you know, stock, if you will, trades on the, the NEO exchange, but you get exposure to the company without having to actually make these, uh, conversion fees. 15:39 So nevertheless, um, that right there is, uh, the video. And, uh, yeah, if you enjoyed, give it a thumbs up. Uh, if you're new, subscribe. Let me know what you think down in the comment section below about this math. 15:49 Is this something that was new to you? Do you have an opinion on this? Um, very, uh, curious to hear what you have to say. 15:55 If you are a new investor, I know I do have a bonus, uh, referral, uh, sign up something down in the description below, either two free stocks or you get a little sign up bonus when you sign up. 16:04 That's a great way of supporting the channel if you did want to go for either the basic or plus. 16:08 At the end of the day, I still think Wealthsimple, as I mentioned in my broker video at the beginning of the year, this is my go-to. Like, I actually just had... 16:15 You know, my wife just opened up a new account, and she switched her investments from Questrade to Wealthsimple. So don't get me wrong. This isn't a bash, uh, in any way, shape, or form. 16:24 It's still what I would say is probably for the masses the best place to go and the best place to start, but I just wanted to make sure people aren't unnecessarily paying for this feature if it's not what they entirely, um, need, and that's, uh, really what it is, uh, at the end of the day. 16:40 But, hey, hope you guys enjoyed the video. As always, our Investing Academy is down below. 16:44 Like I said, if you are new to the stock market and you want, uh, courses, training, support, uh, community, a place to ask questions, like again, Aaron literally, we just had a phone call this week, and he s- these are my buddies telling me, "This is a good video. 16:58 It's-- there's no videos out online on this. You should do it." 17:00 Um, I love the suggestion, and that's really what it's all about is to kinda make these connections with people all across the country who want to learn DIY investing, and they wanna do it in a structured way. 17:11 They wanna know step by step what do I do and get that foundation in place because, yeah, um, it's really, really important, uh, to know what you're doing in the stock market. 17:19 And, uh, that is that first link down below if you'd like to go check that out. That is the Investing Academy. 17:24 Last but not least, if you aren't already on the Blossom app, I would highly encourage you guys to get on there as well if you're a Canadian investor. 17:30 We just passed over ten thousand users, which is a freaking awesome milestone. 17:34 In fact, we're actually at twelve thousand users, so this thing is kinda starting to take off, and we'd love for you to be a part of that as well. Completely free app to join and to take part in. 17:42 That is down in the description or, uh, the pinned comment down below. But as always, I thank you guys for watching. I hope you enjoyed, and I'll see you in the next video