Transcript 0:00 Well, we're all aware of the housing crisis that we're going through here in Canada right now. It is frustrating. It is depressing. 0:05 It's making a lot of people angry, and I get the frustration because it is backed by real numbers, real-life situations. 0:12 Big example here, Vancouver's median house price today sits at nearly 12 times the median household income. That's the situation right now, and that is absolutely ridiculous. 0:23 The question I want to address today, though, is whether Canada is genuinely broken in some unique way or whether we are one of many countries that are caught inside the same systemic failure. 0:34 I wanna cover that off in this video today. Now, the most widely used tool for comparing housing affordability across multiple countries is the median multiple. 0:46 You divide the median house price by the median household income, and you get a ratio. Now, if you come up with a score of 3.0 or below, that is considered affordable. 0:56 You can see on this table here the various categories. Once you're above 5.1, you are in severely unaffordable territory. Above 9, they rate that as impossibly affordable. 1:08 Demographia has tracked this across the English-speaking world for over two decades now. Their 2025 report covers 95 major markets across eight different countries. 1:19 Now, the World Bank, the OECD, they also use the same metrics. That gives us the ability to sort of make an apples to apples comparison across different markets. 1:28 Gallup tracks housing satisfaction annually across the OECD nations, and they asked, "In the city or area where you live, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the availability of good, affordable housing?" 1:42 Their 2024 data shows that only 43% of people in wealthy countries said they were satisfied with the availability of good, affordable housing in their area. The global average, including developing economies, was 50%. 1:57 You'll note that green line here. The world's richest nations have actually fallen below the global median on this measure, and that shift has happened in roughly three years. 2:07 Let's take a moment and look at some of the worst countries that fall into the unaffordability category, and they are pretty much in line with what you might expect. 2:15 Countries like Australia, Canada, Ireland, New Zealand, the UK, and large parts of United States are all in serious trouble, and there is a common thread here. 2:26 These are consistently the countries with the most restrictive land use guidelines. The World Economic Forum addressed this directly in a 2025 report. 2:37 They identified things like exclusionary zoning, slow permitting processes, deep political resistance to new development. They're saying that these have killed the housing supplies across the advanced economies. 2:50 The report says, "Structural barriers to new supply, from outdated zoning laws to politicized development processes, have proven stubbornly resistant to change. 3:00 When supply can't respond to demand, prices are gonna rise." That is Economics 101. Now, we do need to be clear about something here. 3:07 This is not a problem that we've invented here in Canada, but let's look at Canada specifically. Our national median multiple is 5.4. That lands us in the severely unaffordable category. 3:20 Vancouver sitting at 11.8 makes it the fourth least affordable major market in the world behind Hong Kong at 14.4, Sydney at 13.8, and San Jose at 12.1. 3:32 Every single major Canadian market in the report is rated unaffordable. There is not one Canadian city that clears that affordability threshold. Affordable, which is 3.0 or under, zero there. 3:45 At a minimum, every market is at least moderately unaffordable. So Canada is bad, no doubt, but it's also sitting in that same tier as its closest peers. Australia's national median multiple is 9.7. New Zealand is 7.7. 4:00 UK, just higher than Canada at 5.6. China, Hong Kong, of course, sits right at the top. The US, more mixed there. 4:08 Some of the worst markets in the world alongside some affordable cities, some genuinely affordable cities in the Midwest and in the South. 4:16 Now, the UBS Global Real Estate Bubble Index, this adds a different perspective, a different lens that we can look at the same information. It tracks speculative risk rather than raw affordability. 4:27 In its 2025 edition, it flagged elevated bubble risk in Miami, Tokyo, Zurich, Los Angeles, Dubai, and Amsterdam. Toronto and Vancouver sit at a moderate risk under this framework. 4:40 A quick thank you to Harvest ETFs for supporting this video. Harvest is one of Canada's most experienced covered call managers. 4:47 Their core strategy is very straightforward: hold a portfolio of quality stocks, sell call options on a portion of those holdings, and use the premium income generated to pay monthly distributions to investors. 4:59 So for income-focused investors, it is a strategy worth understanding. You can learn more at harvestetfs.com. There'll be a link in the description. 5:08 Now, when you look at this, the, the, the main takeaway, I guess, is that housing stress is showing up across the developed world in different forms, different intensities, but there is a common root here, and that common root is interest rates. 5:21 And we look specifically at the rate cycle between 2021 and 2023. That made everything worse, and it did so not only here, but also around the globe. 5:30 These pandemic era rates, they pushed prices up sharply across most developed markets in a very, very short window. Then what happened was the central banks, they tightened. 5:40 The owners who were sitting on these cheap mortgages, they held on rather than sell and go through a normal cycle, and that pulled inventory out of the market at exactly the wrong moment. 5:50 So the idea that Canada is uniquely broken and that fleeing from the country, moving somewhere else, like I saw in the comment section of the last couple of videos, the thought that that would solve the problem doesn't really hold up well when you review the actual, uh, data. 6:05 Now, another interesting angle we need to talk about is internal migration, and that does tell us a lot. This is the movement from larger markets to suburban, exurban, rural areas. 6:16 Now, in Canada, between 2019 and 2023, the large markets experienced a net loss of nearly 275,000 domestic migrants. 6:27 So this has a direct impact on smaller places, places like Chilliwack in BC, Kelowna, markets on Vancouver Island. 6:34 In Ontario, places like Kitchener, Cambridge, Waterloo, Bradford, London, Guelph, they're all seeing affordability get hit. So that tells you that this is not just a Vancouver problem or not just a Toronto problem. 6:47 It is a system-wide problem, but the smaller markets are now getting caught up, and they're inheriting this bad situation. Little bit of positive news, maybe there is a policy shift starting to build. 6:59 It's moving slowly, as it will. But in 2024, the G7 housing ministers, they met specifically to talk about affordability and being aligned around the supply side reform. 7:10 Things like zoning changes, faster permitting, uh, more housing at the urban fringe. 7:16 A key takeaway from their conference was most of the developed world is experiencing a housing affordability crisis as land becomes more scarce, workers become harder to find, and home prices and rents soar. 7:29 So here we can only kinda hope that when the heads of government start coordinating on a domestic policy issue like this, maybe we're gonna see some political pressure that might follow. 7:38 Keeping that all in mind, reform cycles in housing, obviously they're gonna take a very long time. That's the bad news. But the direction is becoming harder and harder for the governments to ignore. 7:49 Bottom line in this whole scenario, Canada's housing crisis is real. The numbers on that are pretty clear. Vancouver, Toronto rank amongst the worst performing markets in the world on affordability. 7:59 Those are the cold, hard facts. 8:01 But the same forces that are driving those outcomes, the supply restrictions, the land use policy failures, the rate sensitivity, the post-pandemic price surge, those are also hitting buyers in Australia, New Zealand, the UK, significant parts of the US all at the same time. 8:17 So Canada is near the top of that list, but it is a long list, right? 8:21 So I'm not sure whether all of this information is supposed to make us feel better, but at least for now, we know that Canada is amongst a group of countries [laughs] that all are struggling with a housing crisis of their own. 8:32 Doesn't fix things here obviously, but maybe it can help us cope a little bit. Just a little bit. I'm gonna ask you, please don't shoot the messenger, but that's what's happening out there. 8:39 I wanna say thank you for watching. Don't forget to subscribe. We'll see you in the next video.